|
Canadian Archaeological Association 36th Annual Conference, May 7-10, 2003 McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario |
conference abstracts |
Session: Anthropological Archaeology of Mortuary Ritual
Thursday, May 8, 2003
9:00 am – 4:20 pm
Organizers: Mirjana Roksandic, Roger Ivar Lohman
Papers: (15)
Session Abstract: Mortuary behaviour provides insight into the ritual and
ideology of prehistoric societies and produces an essential record of
non-utilitarian behaviour for groups with no written or oral traditions
preserved. Skeletal disposition and taphonomy carry relevant information on
several aspects of mortuary practices, including periburial activities,
disposal, and rituals directed at ancestors. Traditionally, the archaeological
study of burial has relied on the expertise of biological anthropologists and
archaeologists, while the interpretation of mortuary sites to discern the
deceased’s social persona and the group’s ideology has relied on grave goods
and burial architecture, with little reliance on the position of the skeletal
material within the burial, and the rich data available from cultural
anthropology about alternative methods of disposal of the dead. The situation is
changing and the relevance of skeletal disposition for understanding mortuary
behaviours is being recognized. We would like to see increased systematization
of these insights from dispositional taphonomy and cultural anthropology, to
allow meaningful cross-cultural comparisons among mortuary sites. We invite both
methodological papers and case studies on material and ideological aspects of
mortuary practices by researchers from all subfields of anthropology.
Title: Historic Change in the
Mortuary Complexes of the Nisga’a and Haisla, Northwest Coast.
Author: Richard Garvin (Okanagan)
Abstract: British missionaries arrived on
the northern B.C. coast in the mid 1800’s and quickly established themselves
as the representatives of both Christ and Victorian England.
Their goals were originally spiritual, but the means by which they tried
to achieve them were based upon secular interference in specific areas.
Of particular importance to the Church Missionary Society was the
insistence that recent converts abandon their traditional methods of disposing
of the dead and use British-style graveyards and grave markers.
It was believed that by accepting the practice of Christian burial, the
Indigenous peoples were, by extension, accepting all Christian values.
The combination of missionary tolerance towards other aspects of
Indigenous cultures, such as artistic expression, and the Indigenous
community’s own determination in adapting new practices to their cultural
traditions, allowed for syncretistic tendencies in burial patterns and memorial
art to emerge. This paper examines
changes in the mortuary complexes of two Northwest Coast Indigenous groups, the
Nisga’a and the Haisla, resulting from the introduction of Christianity.
The implications of the results offer a cautionary note with regard to
the archaeological analysis of mortuary practices.
Title: Emphasis on Culture in
Taphonomic Studies of Human Remains.
Author: Mirjana Roksandic
(Toronto)
Abstract: Understanding
behaviour of past human groups is the goal of archaeology regardless of the
theoretical perspective it takes. Burials are the closest we can get to ritual
activity of past human societies as they are, with the exception of natural
catastrophe or accidents, inseparable from ritual activity. It has long be
recognized in archaeological literature that the position and orientation of the
deceased are important factors in understanding burial practices and inferring
ideology behind them, therefore these basic attributes figure in most
archaeological reports. The simplistic equation of the position of a skeleton
with the original position of the body has been questioned by growing
understanding of taphonomic processes. In that context, an important parameter
i.e. 'disposition' or 'relative position of the skeleton and individual bones
within a burial' is unreasonably
neglected in most of the taphonomic studies. Systematic recording and
interpretation of information disposition provides can enable better
understanding of disposal of the dead as well as later manipulations in the
context of ancestral ritual. Some examples are examined.
Title: Variation in Burial Patterns from Southwestern
Ontario, from Foraging
times to Historic times.
Author: Susan Pfeiffer (Toronto)
Abstract: Acknowledging that mortuary
rituals vary through space and time, archaeological excavations from
southwestern Ontario can be used to demonstrate the challenges of
interpretation. Archaic use of both off-site cremation and fleshed inhumation
may reflect beliefs, practicality, or both. Iroquoian ossuaries are similar in
some ways, yet variable in others. Even European cemeteries, where we think we
know what we are seeing, can be misinterpreted. Caution must be the first
principle, if we are going to avoid facile interpretations. Testable hypotheses
by past researchers have increased our confidence, especially regarding ossuary
patterning.
Title: Bone Modification and Spatial Context at the Keffer Site, AkGv-14.
Author: Dori Rainey (McMaster)
Abstract: The Keffer site is a Huron
village site located north of Toronto. It was occupied for some time between
A.D. 1475 and 1525, and the large scale excavations that occurred at the site
produced scattered human bone fragments from the middens and houses. Scattered
human bone at other Iroquoian village sites has traditionally been attributed to
the torture and cannibalism of war captives, as described in the Jesuit
Relations. Ethnohistoric and archaeological evidence describe several different
Huron mortuary practices such as burial in a cemetery and reinterment in an
ossuary during the Feast of the Dead. The following is an evaluation of the bone
modification and spatial context of the scattered and fragmentary human remains
in relation to Huron mortuary practices as well as the practice of torture and
cannibalism of war captives. The results indicate that the cultural processes
responsible for the formation of this assemblage at the Keffer site are more
complex than originally thought.
Abstract: Before contact with the West, the
Asabano of Papua New Guinea disposed of the dead differently depending on the
identity of the deceased. Group
members in good standing were laid out on exposure platforms in the bush where
the body was left to decay. Later,
the bones were collected, and those of older or accomplished men were kept in
men’s houses or in stone niches in the bush to be used as an aid in hunting,
warfare, gardening, and male initiations. The
skulls of older women who had been adept at pig raising were retrieved, kept in
women’s dwelling areas, and used for prayer and female initiations.
All other bones were discarded in hollow trees or put in the ground.
Executed witches were thrown into rushing rivers, and some enemies killed
in battle were cooked and eaten. I
discuss the archaeological record that could be inscribed through these disposal
methods, and the potential for determining the meaning behind these practices
with and without the benefit of ethnographic information.
Title: Micro-temporal processes at an Early Bronze Age
Cemetery in the Lake Baikal Region, Siberia.
Authors: Hugh McKenzie
(Alberta) Andrzej Weber(Alberta), Olga Ivanovna Goriunova (Irkutsk)
Abstract: The Early Bronze Age cemetery
Khuzhir-Nuge XIV, located on the northern coast of Lake Baikal, Russia, was used
continuously for over 2000 years. Of the 90 individuals (from 79 graves), 75
have been radiocarbon dated providing a uniquely detailed record of site use
through time. This presentation will explore the history of Khuzhir-Nuge XIV by
reconstructing the cemetery grave by grave. With the addition of each grave, the
character of Khuzhir-Nuge XIV as a place was altered, thus influencing how it
was perceived and used for subsequent interments, which would themselves then
change the character of the place. In this way it is possible to avoid the
tendency to view cemeteries as static places and instead conceive of them as
temporal processes.
Title: A Multidimensional Approach
to the Analysis of Variability in Grave Architecture at a Middle Holocene
Hunter-Gatherer Cemetery Site from Cis-Baikal, Siberia.
Author: Bradley Drouin
(Alberta) , Andrzej Weber (Alberta), Olga Ivanovna Goriunova (Irkutsk)
Abstract: Khuzhir-Nuge XIV, a Middle
Holocene Hunter-Gatherer cemetery is nestled in a small cove on the western
shore of Lake Baikal, Siberia. It is one of the largest hunter-gatherer
cemeteries in all of Siberia spanning about 1800 years of use and composed of 79
graves constructed from numerous stone slabs arranged into cairns covering grave
pits. The graves are orientated in an east-west direction grouped into
discernable rows and clusters. The differences in grave construction both in
terms of stone arrangements and the number of stones used is thought to be
related to age, sex, possible kin relations, status, and temporal and spatial
variables. It is the purpose of this paper to address these issue and attempt to
find meaningful patterns in grave architecture.
Title: Kurma XI: A New Bronze Age
Cemetery on Lake Baikal.
Author: Olga I.
Goriunova (Irkutsk) and Andrzej Weber (Alberta)
Abstract: In the summer of 2002 the
Baikal Archaeology project concentrated its fieldwork on two new Middle Holocene
cemeteries on the shores of Lake Baikal. One of them was Kurma XI located in the
Little Sea area representing the Glazkovo culture of the Late Neolithic to
Bronze Age (c. 5300 – 3300 BP). The fifteen graves excavated produced
archaeological material that is unique in the context of the entire Cis-Baikal
Late Neolithic and Bronze Age mortuary data. This uniqueness regards in
particular a number of grave inclusions. Such objects as the copper/bronze
medallion, fishhooks with copper/bronze barbs, silver ring, large nephrite
rings, and fishhook shanks with anthropomorphic facial images are all first time
ever discoveries. Fieldwork will continue in 2003.
Title: Shamanka II: A New
Neolithic Cemetery on Lake Baikal.
Author: Vladimir Bazaliiskii
(Irkutsk), Andrzej Weber (Alberta)
Abstract: In the summer of 2002 the Baikal
Archaeology Project concentrated its fieldwork on two new Middle Holocene
cemeteries on the shores of Lake Baikal. One of them was Shamanka II located at
the southwest tip of the lake in the town of Kultuk. Of the 24 graves excavated
to date 19 represent the Early Neolithic Kitoi culture (c. 7000 – 6000 BP),
four the Glazkovo culture of the Late Neolithic to Bronze Age (c. 5300 – 3300
BP), and one grave remains unidentified. The Kitoi graves, which contained 39
individuals, are quite similar architecturally and with regard to the
artifactual inclusions and mortuary ritual to the Kitoi graves of the Angara
valley. The assortment of grave goods typically includes shanks of composite
fishhooks, antler bow plates, and zoomorphic figurines. The Shamanka II cemetery
is important because it will redress the existing imbalance in the distribution
of the known Kitoi graves which has been very strongly biased towards the Angara
valley. Fieldwork will continue in 2003.
Title: Disturbance
Patterns at Mortuary Sites of Neolithic Hunter-Gatherers of the Lake Baikal
Region, Siberia.
Author: Cameron Robertson
(Alberta), Andrzej Weber (Alberta), Olga Ivanovna Goriunova (Irkutsk)
Abstract: A significant feature of
mortuary behavior found at the Glazkovo cemeteries Kurma XI and Khuzhir-Nuge
XIV, in Siberia, is extensive post-interment disturbance of the graves. It
appears that prehistoric people routinely reopened the graves after burial and
removed human remains and/or artifacts. Grave disturbance, often referred to as
grave robbing, seems to be looked upon as a barrier to archaeological
interpretation rather than as a genuine cultural process. Despite the frequency
of grave disturbance in mortuary sites all over the world there is a striking
lack of research and literature dedicated to the subject. This paper will
emphasize that grave disturbance is an important cultural activity and will
focus on documenting the range of variability in disturbance patterns within the
archaeological record.
Title: Temporal Patterns of
Cemetery Use among Middle Holocene Hunter-gatherers of the Baikal Region,
Siberia.
Author: Andrzej Weber
(Alberta) , V.I. Bazaliiskii (Irkutsk), O.I. Goriunova (Irkutsk)
Abstract: Three large Middle Holocene
hunter-gatherer cemeteries from the Lake Baikal region in Siberia have been
extensively dated by radiocarbon: Lokomotiv (75 dates) representing the Early
Neolithic Kitoi culture and Ust’-Ida (70) and Khuzhir-Nuge XIV (75), both
associated with the Late Neolithic to Bronze Age Serovo-Glazkovo culture. This
material indicates that many of the larger Serovo-Glazkovo cemeteries in the
Cis-Baikal were used on rare occasions, but over a very long time, up to c. 2000
calibrated years, and with the most frequent use in the middle of that period.
Consequently, many of these cemeteries were used concurrently. The spatial
growth of these large cemeteries was quite complex. At Khuzhir Nuge rows of
graves were established at different locations at about the same time and graves
were added to them at variable frequencies, but many other graves were built
outside of the rows. Similar spatial patterns have been observed elsewhere in
the Cis-Baikal, for example at Ust’-Ida. The dates obtained for the Kitoi
cemetery at Lokomotiv are quite different from Khuzhir-Nuge and Ust’-Ida.
Lokomotiv was used very often, but over much shorter period. This suggests
further significant differences between Kitoi and Serovo-Glazkovo groups.
Title: Extracting Kinship and Social Relationships from
Genetic Data: A Study of
Prehistoric Lake Baikal Populations.
Author: Karen P. Mooder (Alberta),
Theodore G. Schurr (Pennsylvania) and Fiona J. Bamforth (Alberta)
Abstract: DNA
analysis has emerged as a common tool in anthropology over the last decade as
the sensitivity of molecular techniques has improved. Most genetic studies of archaeological populations have been
limited in scope to the estimation of biological affinities between populations
in the absence of archaeological context. In
contrast, this study is attempting to correlate archaeological and molecular
data to explore whether genetic data can be used to extract information about
the population and social structure of mortuary populations.
Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) data has been collected from 77 individuals
from two Neolithic Cis-Baikal cemeteries known as Lokomotiv and Ust’-Ida.
Single and multiple burials were used at both cemeteries and radiocarbon
dates suggest that the two burial types were used contemporaneously.
We observe significant differences in mtDNA haplogroup frequencies as a
function of burial type, suggesting that kinship may have impacted the type of
mortuary treatment proffered in these Neolithic populations.
It may also be possible to delineate marriage practices in these cemetery
populations by correlating genetic data and sex data.
It is our intent to test mtDNA haplogroup frequencies generated from this
study against the conventional hypothesis of patrilocal residence by
hunter-gatherer groups.
Title: An Examination of Grave Disturbance as a Taphonomic
Process.
Author: Misty Weitzel
(Alberta), Andrzej Weber (Alberta), Olga Ivanovna Goriunova (Irkutsk)
Abstract: Grave disturbance initiated
by humans (often a presumption when referred to as looting or robbing) is a
well-known occurrence in the archaeological record.
However, it has not been examined specifically for what it is: a
taphonomic process often having a direct impact on skeletal condition.
Khuzhir-Nuge XIV, a Late Neolithic/Early Bronze Age cemetery in Siberia,
provides a unique opportunity to assess the taphonomic impact of many cultural
processes including grave disturbance. At
least 19 of the 79 burials at Khuzhir-Nuge XIV show evidence of grave
disturbance seen through patterns in grave architecture and the absence of
certain skeletal elements while other elements remain in articulation.
Previous research (Lieverse 1999, 2000) revealed that skeletal
completeness was significantly lower among disturbed graves than undisturbed
graves. Examination of Khuzhir-Nuge
XIV skeletal data in more detail have helped to determine the overall range of
variability among disturbed graves and any meaningful patterns of cultural
activity, which is the goal of a separate Master’s thesis within the Baikal
Archaeology Project. Additionally,
experiments performed at a replicative cemetery site in Edmonton, Alberta have
contributed to knowledge surrounding the effects of grave disturbance.
Title: The Skeleton in Reports on Mortuary Archaeology:
A Statistical Review
Author: Serena Snow (Toronto)
and Barbara Sanders (Toronto)
Abstract: This
paper is a statistical analysis of a number of random articles written on the
subject of ‘mortuary practices’. It
explores the occurrence of the skeleton and related documentation on mortuary
archaeology from journals published around the world. The statistical analysis discussed here involves the detail
in which skeletal material, cultural affiliation, archaeological analysis and
forensic data is discussed in articles focused on burials and mortuary
practices. The central purpose of
this paper is to provide a review of articles written with emphasis on human
skeletal remains, compared to those written with focus on other sub disciplines
in mortuary archaeology.
Title: Social Memory and Mortuary Ritual
Author: Liam Kilmurray (Sheffield)
Abstract:
complexity emerged. In Neolithic Ireland, 'thinking' ancestors required a new temporal order that mortuary ritual helped to develop. To this
end, mortuary rituals at Neolithic monuments employed art, light, material deposits and human burials. These were part of the process of
engineering a memorable event that would contribute significantly to the solidification of social memory and the social identity that underlies
it. Analysis of the interference with the mortuary ritual of the Huron by the Jesuits in the seventeenth century highlights the role of
mortuary ritual in the construction and maintenance of social memory.
Session: 160° of Arctic Archaeology
Thursday, May 8, 2003.
9:00 am – 4:00 pm
Organizer: Julie Ross (Toronto)
Papers: 13
Session Abstract:
This year’s arctic session spans a vast geographic area
and will cover the Palaeoeskimo to Historic periods. The presentations include
an equally impressive range of methodological approaches. These approaches
comprise standard archaeological method of lithic and zooarchaeological analysis
and also the careful examination of archival photographs.
The results promise to enhance and challenge our understanding of the
arctic archaeological record.
Title:
Coastal Resource Utilization on the Western Alaska Peninsula
Author: Laura Smith
(Idaho)
Abstract: Separating
the North Pacific Ocean and the Bering Sea, the Western Alaska Peninsula is a
dynamic environment that is tectonically, seismically and volcanically active.
Living in such close proximity to the ocean has a profound impact on the social,
economic and ideological aspects of a cultural system. The prehistoric Aleut
residents of the Peninsula exploited numerous marine and terrestrial resources,
employing a variety of strategies to cope with periodic episodes of
environmental upheaval. This paper examines offshore resource utilization-
focusing on sea mammals- on the Western Alaska Peninsula and the results of the
Lower Alaska Peninsula Project.
Title: The Rbs Site: Analysis Of An 8000 Year Old
Microblade Production Site In Northwest Alaska.
Author: Julie Esdale (Brown); Jeff Rasic (U.S. National Park
Service)
Abstract: RBS is a buried, single component
microblade production site in northwestern Alaska with 5 overlapping AMS dates
averaging 8,130 14C years BP. The assemblage contains 16 microblade cores, 3
projectile points, 8 expedient flake tools, 631 microblades and over 1787
flakes. Site occupants repaired inset tools and projectiles with bifacial
points, shaped microblade cores, and mass produced microblades for later use.
Contrary to a widespread assumption about raw material conservation in
microlithic technologies, our analysis suggests that microblade production can
be wasteful of lithic material in some contexts. This is likely due to selection
of standardized microblades for existing hafts.
Title: Denbigh Houses in the Noatak National Preserve,
Northwestern Alaska.
Author: Robert Gal (US National Park
Service) and Steven L. Klingler (U.S. National Park Service)
Abstract: Although cultural materials
assignable to the Denbigh Flint Complex have been found from the Alaska
Peninsula to Northern Alaska and throughout the Brooks Range, few dwelling
structures have been identified on Denbigh sites.
This paper discusses five Denbigh Flint Complex sites with stone-ringed
structures located and mapped by U.S. National Park Service archaeologists in
the middle Anisak drainage in 1992, 1998 and 2001.
An inuksuk line may be associated with three of these sites.
Although only one of the structures has been excavated, all appear to be
axial in plan with a medial passage and are similar to Pre Dorset, Independence
I and Sarqaq houses from Arctic Canada and Greenland.
Title: The Cadfael Site Longhouses: Late Dorset
Aggregations on Victoria
Island, Nunavut.
Author: Max Friesen (Toronto)
Abstract: Despite the fact that annual
cycles of aggregation and dispersal are widespread among recent
hunter-gatherers, the recognition and interpretation of aggregation sites in the
archaeological record is difficult. The prehistory of the eastern Arctic
contains a rare exception to this rule, in the form of Late Dorset
"longhouses", which are boulder-outlined features up to 45 metres in length, reasonably interpreted
as communal structures used by aggregated regional groups.
In this paper, I will present new data from the Cadfael Site near
Cambridge Bay, Victoria Island, Nunavut. This is one of largest and most
complex longhouse sites yet recorded, with three large longhouses, a minimum of
seventeen hearth rows, and numerous other features.
Interpretation of this site will centre on its meaning within Late Dorset
regional lifeways, and its potential contribution to more general issues
surrounding the nature and archaeological visibility of hunter-gatherer
aggregations.
Title: Going to the Birds: A Discussion on the Importance
of Avian Resources to Pre-Dorset Subsistence Strategies on Southern Baffin
Island.
Author:
Brooke Milne (McMaster) and S. Donnelly (McMaster)
Abstract: The
Mosquito Ridge site is located near the Great Plain of the Koukdjuak in the
interior of south central Baffin Island. This plain supports hundreds of
thousands of nesting waterfowl every year throughout the spring and summer.
During the annual molt these birds present a rich and reliable food source for
human populations in the region. Typically, subsistence strategies in the Arctic
warm season are synonymous with caribou hunting, and not so much with avian
resources. But the Pre-Dorset who occupied Mosquito Ridge purposely came to the
site to take advantage of this abundance in birds. This paper discusses the
faunal assemblage excavated from Mosquito Ridge and explains where this site
fits into the seasonal round practiced by the Pre-Dorset on southern Baffin
Island.
Title: New Excavation at Tayara Site (KbFk 7).
Authors: Daniel Gendron (Avataq Cultural
Institute), Pierre M. Desrosiers (Sorbonne) and Noura Rahmani (Avataq Cultural
Institute)
Abstract: Tayara (Tyara) is one of the main
sites defining Early Dorset and allowing to Taylor in 1968 to propose continuity
between Pre-Dorset and Early Dorset. The famous "maskette of Tyara"
had largely contributed to its celebrity. Thus, Taylor excavation was very
limited in time and space and did not reveal any structural evidence. Within the
framework of CURA, a research program encouraging communities and universities
collaboration, we visited the site in 2001 to test its archaeological potential.
Convinced by this preliminary testing we organized new excavations last summer
(2002). We are going to present the preliminary result of this first excavation
which has been productive, allowing discovery of structural evidence, hafted
tools, new "art" objects etc.
Fouilles récentes au site de Tayara (KbFk-7)
Tayara (Tyara), est l'un des principaux sites qui a servi
à définir le Dorsétien ancien permettant à Taylor de proposer en 1968 la thèse
de continuité entre le Prédorsétien et le Dorsétien. La célèbre "masquette de Tyara" a aussi largement
contribué à faire connaître ce site. Pourtant, la fouille archéologique de
Taylor fut limitée à 10 jours de fouilles ne révélant aucune évidence de
structures. Dans le carde du programme ARUC, un programme de recherche
encourageant la collaboration entre communautés et universités, nous sommes
retournés en 2001 sur le site pour tester son potentiel archéologique. Ceci
nous a convaincus d'organiser de nouvelles fouilles archéologiques dont la
première campagne s'est déroulée à l'été 2002. Nous allons présenter les
résultats de cette première campagne de fouilles qui s'est avérée très
fructueuse nous permettant, entre autres, de mettre en évidences des
structures, des objets emmanchés, de nouveaux témoins artistique, etc.
Title: Middle Dorset Territory: New Evidence in Southern
Labrador.
Author:
Christopher Wolff (MUN)
Abstract: This paper examines current models
of Middle Dorset cultural distribution in Newfoundland and Labrador. For some
time it has been thought that the “Newfoundland Dorset” was a variant of a
Middle Dorset population that became isolated shortly after their expansion onto
the island of Newfoundland. This assumption is based primarily on stone tool
typologies and distribution of lithic raw materials. My excavations on
Huntingdon Island, just off the coast of the Porcupine Strand in Southern
Labrador, may provide evidence that this assumption is false. New evidence
suggests that the Middle Dorset on the island of Newfoundland may not have been
as isolated as previously thought. In this paper I will argue for an expansion
of what is considered the territory of the “Newfoundland Dorset” onto the
southern shores and islands of Labrador. I will also discuss some suggestions
for future research to examine this hypothesis.
Title: Dorset Raw Material Procurement, Mobility and
Technical Adaptation in Nunavik.
Authors: Pierre M. Desrosiers (Sorbonne)
and Noura Rahmani (Avataq Cultural Institute)
Abstract: Despite the fact that few sources
of raw materials have been identified in Nunavik, it is however possible to deal
with local vs. long distance procurement by means of the study of raw material
management in habitation sites. This also helps us to understand why some
varieties were sought and circulated over a long distance while other raw
materials were limited to local exploitation. The study of some examples shows
that flaking techniques were adapted to raw material sources distribution. The
question of identifying technical tradition, in spite of environmental
limitations to raw material accessibility, is integrated in a broader
discussion.
Approvisionnement en matières premières, mobilité et
adaptation technique durant le Dorsétien au Nunavik.
Malgré le fait que peu de sources de matières premières
aient été formellement identifiées, il est possible d'estimer la provenance
de certaines variétés par l'étude de l'économie de matière première dans
les sites d'habitat. Ceci nous amène à comprendre comment certaines matières
ont été privilégiées et ont circulé sur de longues distances alors que
d'autres ont eu seulement une utilisation locale. L'étude de quelques exemples
montre que les techniques de taille ont été adaptées en fonction de la répartition
des sources. La question de reconnaître des traditions techniques, malgré
l'influence des contraintes du milieu environnant conditionnant l'accessibilité
des matières premières, est abordée.
Title: A Taphonomic Analysis of a Thule Zooarchaeological
Assemblage from Diana Bay (JfEl-10), Nunavik.
Author: Susan Lofthouse (McGill)
Abstract: The Thule occupation of Arctic Québec
(Nunavik) has received relatively minimal archaeological investigation. During
the summer of 2002 a team composed of individuals from Avataq Cultural
Institute, Université Laval, McGill University and local high school students
from Quaqtaq, excavated a Thule site on Illutalialuk at the base of Diana Bay.
JfEl-10 (DIA-10) was partially excavated by Patrick Plumet in 1974 and 1976. In
contrast to Plumet's interpretation of an exclusively Thule occupation for this
site, artifacts from JfEl-10 indicate a mixed context. The analysis of faunal
remains from JfEl-10 will be presented with a specific consideration of the
cultural and natural formation processes that resulted in this fossil
assemblage.
Title: The Evolution of Inuit Subsistence Economies in the
Mackenzie Delta, Northwest Territories.
Author: Matthew Betts (Toronto), T. Max
Friesen (Toronto)
Abstract: The East Channel of the Mackenzie
River was occupied by one of the most populous and complex Inuit cultures in the
Canadian Arctic. The Mackenzie
Inuit, ancestral to modern Inuvialuit practiced a unique and highly productive
subsistence economy that focused on hunting beluga whales which congregate in
the mouth of the East Channel each summer.
Recent archaeological research in the area has produced a high resolution
database of faunal remains documenting the development of this economy.
In this paper, we utilize faunal remains from four archaeological sites,
Cache Point, Pond, Gupuk, and Kittigazuit to trace the evolution of subsistence
systems on the Mackenzie River from the earliest known neo-Eskimo settlement in
the 13th Century to the fluorescence of Mackenzie Inuit culture
several centuries later.
Title: Inughuit Histories: Photographs to Archaeology.
Author: Genevieve LeMoine (Peary-MacMillan Arctic Museum)
Abstract: The rich photographic and film
collections of The Peary-MacMillan Arctic Museum provide an unequalled window
onto the 20th century history of the Inughuit and their role in Arctic
exploration. A recent project to document these images more thoroughly has
revealed their potential for informing archaeological research as well. The
images, and the oral histories gathered with them, provide information that
complements and builds upon historical and archaeological data. Architecture,
material culture, settlement patterns, and subsistence systems are all
documented over a 50 year period of intensive and rapid change in Northwest
Greenland. In this paper I will discuss some of the ways in which these images
and the information read from them are informing archaeological research in the
region.
Title: Anthrosols from two Norse Farms.
Author: Courtney Cameron (Alberta)
Abstract: The Norse settled Iceland in A.D.
874 and in Greenland in A.D. 985. While the Norse were able to maintain their
presence in Iceland, they disappeared from Greenland around A.D. 1500. Many
theories have been developed to explain this abrupt disappearance; including one
in which the collapse of their subsistence strategy is a determining factor. The
subsistence strategy of the Norse was based on agriculture, but supplemented by
hunting and fishing. The infield pastures were an integral component of a
Norse farm as these fields were utilized for growing the majority of the fodder
that sustained their animals through the winter. Infield soil was collected
from two Norse sites (GUS in Greenland and Hals in Iceland) and was chemically
analyzed. The purpose of the analysis was to determine whether the infield soil
quality was enhanced, maintained, or depleted during the period of occupation. Therefore, by determining the soil quality of the
infield, the overall sustainability of Norse farming methods can be examined.
9:00 am – 11:30 am
Papers: 6
Session Abstract:
Regional investigations of the archaeological record are
fundamental to our interpretation of past societies because it is the region
which provides the framework through which we might observe the interaction
between culture and environment and track the flow of populations, resources,
ideas and information over time. This
allows for archaeological explanations of past culture and culture change which
dynamic and complex. In recent
years archaeology has redefined earlier constructs of “the region”.
The region is no longer simply an environmental backdrop for culture, but
a flexible, conceptual tool capable of reflecting the full-range of cultural
actions, and embedded with social meaning.
With recent developments in mind, this session proposes to bring together
researchers from diverse theoretical and geographical backgrounds in order to
identify the range of topics considered under the umbrella of regional
approaches today and to demonstrate the ways that regional archaeology is
essential to their research objectives.
Title: Shifting Views in Archaeological Histories of the
Northwest Coast.
Author: Aubrey Cannon (McMaster)
Abstract: A review of Northwest Coast
research shows the interpretive luxury afforded by analytical scales that are
either site-centric or supra-regional in scope. Regionally conceived studies, in
contrast, reveal particular patterns of local variability that are the basis for
more precise historical interpretations. Local historical narratives, though no
more inherently accurate than extant supra-regional frameworks, provide a more
ready basis for further research programs designed to evaluate their accuracy
and to extend their interpretive scope. Comparison and evaluation of different
approaches to Northwest Coast archaeology emphasize the need to define and
conduct research at regional scales of analysis appropriate to the historical
processes and events that are the focus of interpretation.
Title: The Porcupine Strand: A Multi-ethnic Landscape in
Central Labrador.
Abstract: The Porcupine Strand Archaeology
Project, initiated in 2001 was conceived as a regional archaeology project aimed
at defining the pre-contact interactions between the Indian and Palaeo-eskimo
populations who inhabited the coast of Labrador.
The study area, a 40km stretch of sand dune coastline adjacent to many
rocky islands, was defined by three distinct concepts of region: 1) as a
geographically unique setting on the Labrador coast; 2) as an archaeologically
empty landscape, reflecting the lack of archaeological fieldwork, and 3) as a
potential zone of inter-ethnic interaction located close to the northern and
southern limits of several pre-contact cultural expansions.
Archaeological survey and geomorphological work undertaken in this region
are helping to redefine the Strand as a multiethnic landscape occupied by at
least 8 distinct populations over 7000 years. As work progresses a complex, changing and contingent social
landscape is emerging, but comprehending this landscape requires that many
different scales of regional behavior are interwoven.
Title: Fluctuating
Boundaries in Huron Prehistory.
Author: Peter Ramsden (MUN)
Abstract: This paper considers the Huron
region in south-central Ontario over a 700 year time span, from geographical and
socio-political points of view. It
attempts to reconcile the notion of a cultural region that has clearly
discernable long-term cultural continuity, with changes that the region exhibits
in geographical extent and location, as well as political and ethnic structure.
Title: An Agency Centered Approach to Regional Archaeology:
Natufian Interaction in the Levant.
Author: Carla Parslow (Toronto)
Abstract: Previous research on the Natufian
has revealed much about past ecology and environment in the Natufian's core and
periphery areas, its technology and material culture, and its settlement and
subsistence strategies. Within the
core area, there is overall consistency in technology and material culture,
while variability is much greater in the periphery.
Previous researchers have explained this variability primarily from an
ecological perspective, and have given little attention to social relations or
the role of production, maintenance and transformation of social institutions in
this variability. Unlike previous
ecologically focused work, this research focuses on the interactions of
individuals and groups of individuals who made, used, and exchanged artifacts
and knowledge about artifacts at the regional scale. We can better understand variability between the core and
periphery through a regional investigation that emphasizes social relations
rather than environmental factors
Title: A Dynamic Neolithic Landscape in the Wadi Ziqlab, Northern
Jordan.
Author: E.B. Banning (Toronto)
Abstract: At the end of the Pre-Pottery Neolithic in the southern Levant, widespread abandonment of large and densely-occupied settlements
has led many archaeologists to assume regional abandonment in the face of possible environmental deterioration. An alternative hypothesis, that
the entrenchment of food-producing economies encouraged a dispersed, dendritic settlement system, has been the focus of investigations in
Wadi Ziqlab, northern Jordan. The discovery of small Late Neolithic farmsteads scattered along the ancient watercourse has implications not
only for economic changes but also for change in social organization and ideology.
Thursday, May 8, 2003.
9:00 am – 12:00 pm
Organizer: Christophe Rivet (ICHAM)
Papers: 6 (+2 discussion sessions)
Session Abstract:
Linking archaeology and the environment in
archaeological heritage management. The UNESCO World Heritage Convention considers “that
the deterioration or disappearance of any item of the cultural or natural
heritage constitutes a harmful impoverishment of the heritage of all the nations
of the world” and as such recognises that there is a harmonious
relationship between both. Archaeology, probably more than any other heritage
discipline, explores this relationship through such studies as settlement
patterns, agricultural techniques, or land occupation. Hence, when translated
into archaeological heritage management, understanding this relationship becomes
highly instructive in understanding the nature of what is identified as
heritage, in identifying its values, in defining the historical as well as
environmental context of the resource, and finally in determining the pressures
at work in conservation. How does the environment influence human settlement and
human history? How do these locations and events affect present preservation and
interpretation of archaeological resources? When natural events exert pressure
on the archaeological resource, how do we mitigate the effects without
compromising the integrity of the environment? The first part of this session will explore the
relationship between human communities and nature. The second will look at
cultural heritage and nature’s impact on it.
La Convention du patrimoine mondial de l’UNESCO considère
“que la dégradation ou la disparition d’un bien du patrimoine culturel et
naturel constitue un appauvrissement néfaste du patrimoine de tous les peuples
du monde”. Celle-ci admet une relation harmonieuse entre l’un et l’autre
type de patrimoine. L’archéologie, probablement plus que toute autre
discipline en patrimoine, explore cette relation par le biais, entre autres,
d’études sur les types d’établissements, les techniques d’agricultures,
ou l’occupation et l’exploitation du territoire. Dépendants de la terre qui
subvient à leurs besoins, les humains se sont adaptés à leur environnement.
Cette symbiose se matérialise par des marques culturelles laissées par les
communautés, des traces à la fois tangibles et intangibles de leur présence.
Chaque aspect du paysage qui les entoure comporte un nom et un sens qui reflète
leurs valeurs et leurs besoins. Cette relation se perpétue jusqu’à ce que le
site soit abandonné. Le paysage, cependant, continue d’évoquer la mémoire
de cette relation passée tout en se transformant. Un équilibre nature/culture
est maintenu par la mémoire associée au site par la tradition orale, le savoir
traditionnel ou encore l’interprétation du site. Ce même environnement peut
représenter un défi de conservation important. Lorsque mise en application en
gestion du patrimoine archéologique, la compréhension de cette relation
devient particulièrement utile afin de comprendre la nature de ce qui est
identifié comme patrimoine, d’identifier ses valeurs, de définir le contexte
historique et environnemental de la ressource, et finalement afin de déterminer
les formes de stress qui affectent sa conservation. De quelle manière
l’environnement affecte-t’il l’établissement des groupes et leur histoire
? De quelle manière ces endroits et ces événements affectent-ils la
conservation et l’interprétation des ressources archéologiques ? Lorsque les
forces naturelles exercent une pression sur la ressource archéologique, de
quelle manière pouvons-nous en réduire les impacts sans créer d’effets néfastes
sur l’environnement ?
Title: The Oral History of Fathom Five
Author: Lenore Keeshig-Tobias (George Brown)
Abstract: In the oral tradition of the
Anishnabek, there was a time when the when the waters of the Great Lakes began
to rise and flow in the opposite direction. This was the result of an enormous
dam built by a giant beaver. Nokomis (grandmother) caught the beaver. In order
to escape the old woman’s grasp, the giant beaver had to dig through his dam
and the water carried him away. The lake returned to its normal level. Anishnabe
storytellers say that the above-mentioned story took place at a time when Lake
Huron poured into Georgian Bay. In addition to the story of the giant beaver,
elders from the Chippewas of Nawash First Nation tell stories of people walking
to Manitoulin Island, of fishermen hearing voices under the water, of
whirlpools, and about battles between an eagle and a sea serpent. Fathom
Five’s lakebed mapping project has revealed a number of underwater features
that give evidence that thousands of years ago, deep channels were carved into
the escarpment within a relatively short span of geological time and that the
water in Lake Huron did indeed flow into Georgian Bay. The discovery of ancient
waterfalls and riverbeds means that most of Fathom Five was once dry land at a
time when Georgian Bay flowed out toward the St. Lawrence, through the French
River area. Getzijiig (elders or old-timers) is a group of Nawash elders who are
concerned about the preservation of their language, the loss of certain words,
concepts and ideas, and meet weekly. In this manner, Getzijiig is handing on
their knowledge to younger generations. Anishnabe (Ojibway) elders have long claimed that their
language and their stories come from the land. Thus the oral history of Fathom
Five begins with Getzijiig, with ancient Anishnabe stories, Anishnabemowin (the
language) and the people’s relationship to the land and water.
Title: Rediscovering Past Landscapes: Mapping Ancient
River Channels, Waterfalls, Beaches and Caves on the Lakebed of Fathom Five
National Marine Park
Author: Steve Blasco, Andrew Promaine,
Jim Shearer, Mike Lewis, Bill Fox, (Geological Survey of Canada)
Abstract: New high-resolution digital sonar
mapping techniques have been employed to investigate the Huron-Georgian Bay
lakebed between Tobermory and Fitzwilliam Island. Four bedrock channels, 3
drowned waterfalls, and several relict beaches and caves have been located and
mapped in water depths ranging from 15 to 90 metres. The now submerged Niagara
Escarpment north of Tobermory was subaerially exposed for at least 3 time
periods between 9600 and 7200 years ago. Lake waters were 30 to 55m lower than
present. During these low lake stands the 4 bedrock channels were occupied by
waters flowing from Lake Huron into Georgian Bay over 3 ancient waterfalls.
Bedrock caves and beaches were exposed or were generated.
Low lake shorelines, riverbanks, beaches and caves would have formed
potential occupation sites for paleoindians migrating across this
‘landbridge’ between the Bruce Peninsula and Manitoulin Island.
Title: Giigoonh Mnjikan: Journey to the Fish Weirs
Author: Sheryl Smith (Parks Canada)
Abstract: The history of the Mnjikaning
Fish Weirs National Historic Site of Canada extends back five millennia.
Aboriginal people maintained a complex system of underwater fences there for
harvesting fish. In the Ojibway telling of the creation of the world, the
Creator gave each species of living thing on the earth a different purpose to
fulfill. The fish were told to come together at certain times of the year and to
hold council. At these times, the People could more readily access them for
food. Remarkably, in spite of all the changes the Atherley Narrows has undergone
over the centuries, the fish still hold to their role in creation and come
together at Mnjikaning every spring and fall. Over time, the Mnjikaning site
became a traditional meeting place for Aboriginal nations and was officially
recognized as nationally significant in 1982. The Mnjikaning Fish Fence Circle
has produced a video integrating traditional Aboriginal teachings with
scientific information to educate the public about this rare and ancient place.
Title: Une approche globalisante des traces humaines dans
le paysage: le projet d’inventaire et d’atlas des lieux de mémoire de la
Nouvelle-France au Québec et en France
Author: Alain Roy (CIEQ)
Abstract: La Nouvelle-France a souvent
fait, au Québec et en Amérique française, l’objet de préoccupations
patrimoniales. Associée surtout à une quête des origines, on y a vu un
vecteur d’identité dont la valorisation a varié au cours du temps. Il n’en
demeure pas moins que cette époque a marqué profondément et de diverses façons
le paysage québécois. Que ce soit par le biais du patrimoine bâti – les
habitations et les sites archéologiques –, de repères de mémoire –
rappels commémoratifs ou interprétatifs d’un événement associé à un site
concret – ou par des traces humaines dans le paysage – découpage foncier,
routes et ouvrages de génie –, les vestiges qui en subsistent prennent
diverses formes, dont la relation entre eux n’a pas souvent été prise en
compte. Le projet d’inventaire et d’atlas des lieux de mémoire de la
Nouvelle-France propose à cet égard un regard nouveau sur cette époque. En
recensant dans un même inventaire ces divers types de lieux tout en indiquant
les relations entre eux, on restitue dans l’espace une dynamique vivante, qui
permet de saisir de façon globale les interactions entre ces lieux, entre les
hommes et le paysage, ainsi qu’entre le Québec et la France. Ce faisant,
l’inventaire devient à la fois relais de mémoire, en rappelant ces phénomènes,
et outil d’histoire, en permettant une meilleure compréhension des dynamiques
historiques.
Title: Accessing the Historic Landscape of the Eastern
James Bay Cree: The Evidence of Oral Tradition
Author: Susan M. Preston, University of
Waterloo
Abstract: A significant challenge to
understanding the past lifeways of some hunter-gatherer cultures is the dearth
of physical remains of their activity in the landscape, particularly where
continuity with the past has been broken by historic and current colonial
interests. By careful analysis of
archival oral tradition recordings, evidence can be retrieved not only for the
details of subsistence activity, but also for past cultural constructions of the
lifeworld. Reporting on such
research, this paper illustrates how interpretation of Eastern James Bay Cree
oral tradition revealed the symbolic representation of landscape, or
environmental, meaning and experience at the outset of the 20th century.
In combination with interpretive research such as this, the digital
preservation of historic recordings is consistent with current efforts by UNESCO
to develop an international convention on the safeguarding of intangible
cultural heritage.
Title: New Directions in Protecting the Intangible: UNESCO
Initiatives and Heritage
Author: Christophe Rivet (ICOMOS)
Abstract: The notion of intangible values
has been inherent to many international documents that aim to protect natural
and cultural heritage. From the Venice Charter to the World Heritage Convention,
and more recently the Convention on Biodiversity, UNESCO, NGOs and other
international bodies have perceived the intangible dimension of heritage without
yet tackling issues of definition, identification and protection.
UNESCO has been actively engaged since 1998 in developing tools to
identify and protect intangible heritage. Through the “Masterpieces of the
Oral and Intangible Heritage of Humanity” project, UNESCO recognizes cultural
spaces or forms of cultural expression that are significant to mankind as a
whole. How will this affect our perception of heritage? How will our work as
heritage conservation practitioners be redefined? This paper will present the
ICOMOS charters and main international conventions that mention the intangible
aspect of heritage, will present the UNESCO initiatives, and will define some
issues and challenges that they might represent for the archaeological heritage
conservation practitioners.
Open Workshop Session: Rethinking Artifact Curation:
Current Perspectives and Future Options
Thursday May 8, 2003
1:30 – 3:00 pm
Convenor: Kathryn Denning (McMaster)
Format: Open discussion.
Abstract: This
open workshop is meant to provide space and opportunity for informal discussion
of issues in artifact custody and storage, sensitive curation education
programs, possibilities and plans for artifact repositories that honour First
Nations concerns, collaborative exhibit design, and related topics. All are
welcome to attend.
Session: Spatial Analysis
Thursday, May 8, 2003.
1:30 pm – 4:40 pm
Papers: 8
Title: Ridge-Top Cache Pits and Settlements: Indications of
Regional Conflict at Kitwancool Lake.
Author:
Paul Prince (Trent)
Abstract:
Cache pit features comprise a ubiquitous site type in the interior and
coastal river valleys of British Columbia, but their presence is rarely
considered informative beyond being evidence of storage.
This paper reports on recent survey work at Kitwancool Lake where an
interesting association between cache pits and very steep landforms is noted.
House-pit and refuge or “look-out” sites occur in similar defensible
positions. These site locations are interpreted within the context of a model of
regional interaction that included conflict. It is suggested that meaningful
associations in the distribution of cache pit sites in other regions may also be
detectable if examined in the context of trends in local prehistories
constructed on the basis of more traditional evidence.
Author: Rudy Reimer/Yumks (First Heritage
Archaeological Consulting/Squamish Nation)
Abstract: The geographical extent and
antiquity of use of high elevation alpine and sub-alpine environments are often
viewed by archaeologists as to extreme and harsh for past human settlement and
use. But what is the actual extent of the archaeological evidence in the
mountain regions of western North America? Recent archaeological survey and
literature review indicate that the use of high elevation areas throughout
northwest North America is variable, expressed through variable; site types,
resources use, technological orientation, and temporal resolution. Suggestions
for future research in different mountainous/alpine regions are presented.
Title: Changing Settlement and Technology from Terminal
Archaic to Middle Maritime Woodland in the Lower St. John-South Central New
Brunswick Area.
Author: Susan Blair (Toronto)
Author: Bill Allen (Independent)
Abstract: Behind the mask of the rocky Thirty Thousand Islands of Muskoka
and Parry Sound Districts in Ontario's northeastern Georgian Bay lie sporadic
remnants of Algoma phase post glacial beaches. Tucked along the archipelago of
that period are archaeological sites which are revealing influences from Lake
Superior to the St. Lawrence Valley. Multicomponent Canadian Shield sites from
Shebeshekong Bay to the Severn River reveal hints of geographically distant
cultural influences. A northern Parry Sound site yielded a rare biconically
drilled coal gorget similar to those found in glacial kames of the Ohio Valley.
A Muskoka site of apparent Hopewellian influence had a mound with a fabric
pouch, copper beads, raw copper, cache blades, blocked end tubular pipes and
exotic cherts. All of these sites fall within the narrow range of elevations of
Algoma phase raised beaches. This illustrated presentation will show
provenienced artifactual evidence and call for a more intentional regional
investigation. We stand a better chance of understanding the extent of Late
Great Lakes-St. Lawrence cultural influences if we include thorough study of
Algoma phase post glacial beaches as a future direction of the archaeological
assessment of Georgian Bay.
Title: Refining the Definition of Cultural Levels at
Karabi Tamchin: A Quantitative Approach to Vertical Intra-Site Spatial Analysis.
Author: Kirsten Anderson (Manitoba) and Ariane Burke (Manitoba
Abstract: The visual identification of
archaeological levels can be difficult when the stratigraphy is complex. In this
study, a Geographic Information System (GIS) is applied to a
three-dimensional intra-site spatial analysis of artifact and bone distributions
from Karabi Tamchin, a Middle Paleolithic site from the Crimea, Ukraine. The
distribution of archaeological materials is examined using the K-means
statistical clustering method, combined with a series of data transformations to
identify and interpret the vertical and horizontal spatial organization of the
site. Results indicate that K-means cluster analysis, used in conjunction with
GIS, provides a means of testing the integrity of archaeological levels as well
as identifying palimpsests. Within levels, K-means is used to identify discrete
clusters of archaeological materials that can be used to reconstruct and compare
patterns of spatial organization on the site.
Title: The Relationship
Between Spatial and Social Order at Ninstints, Queen Charlotte Islands, B.C.: An
Exercise in Space Syntax Analysis.
Author: Katherine
Patton (Toronto)
Abstract: Space syntax analysis is a method
frequently used in archaeology to illustrate the extent to which architectural
forms engage in reciprocal relationships with society.
It has been successfully applied in contemporary historic and prehistoric
settings where settlement remains are well-defined and well-preserved.
Space syntax analysis has not yet been incorporated into archaeological
household or settlement studies of villages on the Northwest Coast of North
America. This may be due largely to
the relatively poor conditions of most village remains and tendency toward small
scale archaeological excavations on the Coast.
This paper presents the results of an exploratory exercise into how space
syntax analysis could be applied to Northwest Coast historic villages and gauges
the method’s efficacy in archaeological contexts.
The study assesses the continuity of open space within the historic Haida
village site of Ninstints (or SgA’ngwa-i), Queen Charlotte Islands, B.C.,
using Hillier and Hanson’s Alpha Analysis.
The permeability of Haida houses is assessed from a rudimentary floor
plan, created from diagrams and descriptions of historic period Haida housing,
using Gamma Analysis. The
results are interpreted to reflect the relationship between inhabitants, and
inhabitants and strangers, but are also tested against what is known about 19th
century Haida social organization.
Title: Analysis of the Diagnostics Recovered from the Hwy
63 Extension Project.
Authors: Courtney Cameron (Alberta) and
Sandra Pentney (Alberta)
Abstract: In 2000 and 2001 archaeological
testing and excavations took place on the Hwy 63 extension project north of Fort
MacKay, Alberta. Approximately 250,000 items were collected, including 13
diagnostic artifacts. This paper is a preliminary attempt to establish the
nature of pre-contact occupations present in the study area. The styles of the
diagnostic artifacts suggest that the area around Fort MacKay was occupied
during the Middle Forest period. The diagnostics found are characteristic of
both taiga/barrenland and northern plains environs.
Title: Behavioural variability at the Middle to Upper
Paleolithic Transition in Central and Eastern Europe.
Author: Ildiko Horvath (McGill)
Abstract: The birth of modern human culture
and the changes that precipitated human cultural and biological evolution at the
transition from the Middle to the Upper Paleolithic have fueled one of the
longest-lasting and most active debates in Paleolithic archaeology and
palaeoanthropology. At the core of this debate lie markedly different views on
the nature of the transition. While the interpretation of the archaeological and
palaeoanthropological record has led the majority of archaeologists to believe
that a clear break is evident between the Middle and the Upper Paleolithic, many
contend that the shifts in human culture in the earliest phases of the Upper
Paleolithic reflect amplifications of gradual changes that first emerged during
the Mousterian. Recent evidence provided by archaeological industries of the
transitional period and the early Upper Paleolithic in Central and Eastern
Europe points to marked regional differences that characterize hominid cultural
behaviour at this crucial time. As reflected by the archaeological material from
several roughly contemporaneous sites on the Middle Prut Valley, Romania,
rupture and continuity are both integral to the changes that triggered
acceleration in cultural development at the beginning of the Upper Paleolithic.
Thursday, May 8, 2003.
1:30 pm – 4:40 pm
Session Organizer: Rhonda R. Bathurst (McMaster)
Papers: 7 + discussant (Ann Herring, McMaster)
Session Abstract:
Health: A condition of being sound in body, mind and
spirit - especially freedom from physical disease or pain (Merriam-Webster).
Traditional definitions of health emphasize the physical condition.
Therefore, the analysis of health in past societies has long been the
domain of physical anthropology and osteology. But the context of these physical
studies have frequently been removed from, or presented in isolation of, their
cultural associations. As a compliment to human physical studies, archaeology centres on the material remains of our
cultural past, providing context, depth and additional evidence to
interpretations of the past. This symposium draws together a multidisciplinary
compliment of innovative methods and perspectives that offer future directions
toward providing a more holistic interpretation of health in the past.
Title: Towards Defining Standards of Archaeoparasite
Analysis.
Author: Rhonda R. Bathurst (McMaster)
Abstract: Many interpretations of health in
past human societies insinuate the likelihood of parasite infection, but
relatively few studies have sought primary evidence of this condition. The study
of ancient parasites is a relatively new specialization in archaeological
studies that has developed intensively over the last 20 years. These studies are
increasingly used in ecological and epidemiology interpretations of past
societies, but as yet are not standard procedures at archaeological sites. This
paper discusses the process of archaeoparasite analysis, using the author’s
current research on the Pacific Northwest Coast as an example. It will discuss
some standard sampling procedures, taphonomical issues, quantitative measures
and the interpretive benefits of incorporating such studies more frequently into
archaeological and physical anthropological studies.
Title:
Native North American Resistance and Susceptibility to Infectious Disease: an
Anthropological Approach.
Author:
Linda Larcombe (Manitoba)
Abstract: The human immune system has
evolved to allow individuals to survive exposure to the disease environment in
which a population exists. A recent study examined 300 contemporary Manitoba
Aboriginal and Caucasian individuals and it was demonstrated that the genetics
of the immune systems of Aboriginals differed from that of the Caucasians. These
findings suggest that the immune systems of Aboriginal and Caucasian populations
differ in their ability to mount an effective immune response against certain
infectious diseases. This hypothesis will be tested through a combined analysis
of archaeological, ethnohistoric and molecular data from past and present
populations. This research will contribute directly to our understanding of the
environmental and genetic pressures in which the immune response of Aboriginal
populations evolved.
Title:
Developmental Enamel Defects and the Study of Archaeological Fauna.
Author: Shelley Saunders (McMaster)
and Charles Fitzgerald
Abstract:
Anthropological interest in macroscopic and microscopic developmental defects of
enamel (excluding opacities) has traditionally focused on humans, although there
is a growing interest in their prevalence among non-human primate species, both
in the present and the past (Guatelli-Steinberg, 2001). Nutritional and disease
stresses have been demonstrated to be common causes of these defects such that a
wide literature uses their prevalence among past human populations as a marker
of health status. At the same time, detailed knowledge of the microscopic
processes of tooth enamel formation in human and non-human primates has
progressed such that we know that histological studies are necessary to
precisely and accurately determine the ages of defect formation and their
association to specific metabolic disruptions. This paper reviews some of the
recent developments in the study of humans as well as some other modern faunal
species to address the implications of this work for archaeological
reconstructions of the past.
Title: The Use of Peripheral Quantitative Computed
Tomography (pQCT) to Examine Sex and Age Related Change in Bone Density in a 19th
Century Southern Ontario Population.
Authors: M. Selbie, S.C. Agarwal,
S. Saunders, and C. Webber (McMaster)
Abstract: Bone loss and fragility is a
common disorder affecting modern Western populations. The examination of
osteoporosis in the archaeological record can contribute much to our
understanding of the disease in both the past and the present. Commonly used in
a clinical setting, Peripheral Quantitative Computed Tomography (pQCT) is a
non-invasive imaging technique for the examination of bone quantity. The purpose
of this study was to examine age and sex-related changes in bone density in a 19th
century archaeological sample from the St. Thomas Anglican Church Cemetery from
Belleville, Ontario. Left radii
from a total of 170 individuals (both male and female) were scanned using a
Stratec pQCT scanner. Patterns of age-related in cortical bone density were
analyzed and compared between the sexes. This study demonstrates that pQCT is an
effective technique for the examination of radial cortical bone density in
archaeological bone.
Title: Identifying Disease in Faunal Remains at the
Histological Level.
Author: Tanya von Hunnius (McMaster)
Abstract:
The use of histology on human skeletal and mummified remains is a well known
method. In this context, it is used
to estimate age, understand decomposition of tissue or taphonomic history of the
burial environment and diagnose disease. This
latter application is an area that is seldom if rarely used by zooarchaeologists.
Macroscopic observation of pathology is a good beginning to an analysis,
but a microscopic perspective of faunal material can provide an additional
perspective of osseous response to stress and disease.
Those studies, which have used histology to help diagnose pathology in
faunal remains, will be discussed. However,
studies in human paleohistopathology will be relied on to emphasize the utility
of microscopy in zooarchaeology. Identifying
disease in faunal remains at the histological level has the potential to suggest
new evolutionary models and indicate possible routes of transmission between
humans and animals for some diseases.
Title: Isotopic Evidence of
Anemia among the Coastal Maya.
Authors: Christine D. White (Western), Jocelyn S. Williams
(Calgary) and Fred J. Longstaffe
(Western)
Abstract: Because health is critically dependent on nutrition,
paleodietary isotopic analysis can
be a useful means of testing dietary causes for non-specific pathology such as
anemia. Found in high frequencies
among ancient Maya populations, anemia has often been attributed to heavily
maize dependent diets. Bone
collagen of 67 individuals from two Postclassic coastal sites, Marco Gonzalez
and San Pedro, Belize, was analysed
for stable carbon and nitrogen isotope ratios in order to test dietary
hypotheses for the etiology of anemia. Neither
insufficient protein nor a high carbohydrate (maize) diet appear to be the cause
of anemia at these sites. Maize
consumption did not differ significantly between normal and anemic individuals.
However, anemic individuals consumed foods from significantly lower
trophic levels, in this case more shellfish and/or other marine invertebrates.
In general, the iron content of shellfish and fish does not differ, so a
dietary difference in iron is not the likely cause of anemia.
Low trophic level copepods (aquatic crustaceans) are hosts of the
“broad fish tapeworm” or Diphyllobothrium latum which can cause
pernicious anemia. The possibility that the presence of these organisms could
have caused anemia in the Maya at these sites is investigated.
Discussant: Ann Herring (McMaster)
Session: Who's on First? Studies of Early Human
Occupation in Canada
Thursday, May 8, 2003.
3:20 pm – 5:00 pm
Organizer: Chris Ellis (Western)
Papers: 5
Author: D. Brian Deller, Christopher
Ellis & Roger King (Western)
Abstract: Excavated in 1981 and 1982, the
Crowfield site near London, Ontario would be a typical small Paleoindian
campsite except for the presence of a large pit feature remnant associated with
hundreds of pieces of at least 200, purposefully burned, heat-fractured,
predominantly Onondaga chert, artifacts. Although the subject of a preliminary
published report, the site has not been reported in detail and there are several
misconceptions about it in the literature. As aids to reconstructing the
contents of the feature, its nature and its meaning, we provide here an update
on recent research focusing particularly on continuing efforts at artifact
refitting, mapping of fragments, and soil analyses.
Title: The Spanish River Biface cache and Shield Archaic
Caching Behavior in the Boreal Forest Region.
Author: P. J. Julig,
and Dorian Jean (Laurentian)
Abstract: A large cache of oval biface preforms and some uniface tool
types from the Spanish River basin were examined technologically, typological
and for lithic source. The lithic source was determined by minimally-destructive
FTIR methods to be exclusively HBL (Hudson Bay Lowland) cobble chert, likely
from secondary deposits in northern Ontario. Although mostly bifaces, the cache
represents a used tool kit containing many tool types and used-edge
configurations. This is similar to those present tool edge configurations
present in other early pre-ceramic regional assemblages. The cache is
interpreted within the context of other known lithic caching behavior in the
boreal forest region.
Title: Technological
Change at the Palaeoindian-Early Archaic Transition: An Examination of Formal
End Scrapers from the Lower Great Lakes.
Author: Katherine McMillan (Western)
Abstract: This paper presents the results
of a detailed comparison between Great Lakes Palaeoindian and Early Archaic
Nettling end scrapers. The
purpose of this research was to assess claims regarding the changing nature of
lithic production strategies during the Palaeoindian-Archaic transition.
In contrast to highly mobile Palaeoindian populations, who relied on
single, high-quality primary chert outcrops, Archaic populations have been
characterized as relatively sedentary groups who exploited various local,
low-quality and often secondary lithic sources.
The results of this study, though, show that the Nettling population
exploited a large territory, moving between at least two lithic sources, a
strategy that may have reduced raw material constraints faced by Palaeoindians.
Lithic production in the Archaic has been described as haphazard, as
opposed to the highly standardized Palaeoindian production techniques.
Few differences, though, are noted in end scraper blank production
between the two time periods. One
exception is that Early Archaic toolmakers were apparently becoming less
selective in their choice of blanks, with some specimens requiring substantially
more post-detachment modification than Palaeoindian forms.
These results confirm the beginnings of a technological shift, but
emphasize its transitional rather than abrupt nature and provide unique insight
into Early Holocene adaptations in the Lower Great Lakes.
Title: Late Plano Occupation at
the St. Louis Site, FfNk-7, Central Saskatchewan.
Authors: LJ Butch Amundson (Stantect Consulting Ltd.) and David
Meyer (Saskatoon)
Abstract:
The St. Louis Site, FfNk-7, is located on a terrace of the lower South
Saskatchewan River in central Saskatchewan. The site was discovered in the
summer of 2002 while fulfilling the CRM requirements for Saskatchewan Highways
and Transportation's proposed St. Louis Bridge. Buried by a series of over-bank,
vertical accretion events, the site contains as many as thirteen cultural
occupations between at least 8400 and 4590 BP. The stratigraphic column is over
2 m thick and contains numerous old soil horizons developed on massive, calcium
carbonate-rich silt. Long-since abandoned, the terrace is a narrow remnant of a
former a flood plain, much of which has been eroded away by the meandering of
the river channel. This former flood plain revealed evidence of repeated bison
kill and butchery, as well as habitation events. Of specific interest to the
current presentation are cultural layers VII and VIII. From Layer VII we
recorded the remains of a short-lived hearth, a chipping station; bison remains
including a skull whose horn core spread indicates an extinct species, fish and
waterfowl remains and the base of a Late Plano projectile point. This layer has
been radiocarbon dated using bone to a normalized age of 7810 +/- BP
(Beta-173609). Layer VIII, with a radiocarbon age of 8400 +/- 70 BP
(Beta-173610) contains the remains of bison, fish, rabbit, and grouse as well as
a possible shell sequin.
Title: By Land or Sea? A Review of Current Evidence
Supporting a Coastal Route for the First North Americans Penetrating South of
Beringia.
Author: Knut R. Fladmark (SFU)
Abstract: This paper offers an updated
review of the two dominant theories concerning how people first spread south of
Beringia in North America during the Late Pleistocene.
They are (1) via an interior “ice-free corridor” between Laurentide
and Cordilleran ice masses, and (2) via a “coastal route”, or chain of
unglaciated refugia around the Northwestern Pacific margin of the continent.
In summary, it now seems coalescent glaciers blocked virtually the entire
“corridor” during the Late Wisconsin glaciation and that a continuous,
inhabitable, ice-free strip did not open up in that area before about 11.5-11.3
kya. Dated archaeological sites
also support a south-to-north movement by the first people penetrating into that
mid-continental region. In
contrast, rapidly accruing evidence indicates that significant portions of the
outer Pacific margin of North America, stretching almost continuously from the
Bering Land Bridge to the southern margin of Late Wisconsin glaciation, were
ice-free and supporting significant terrestrial biota by (at least) 13-14 kya.
Thus, a coastal route was clearly available to humans 1500 to 3500+ years
before the so-called “ice-free corridor”.
The current absence of equivalently old coastal archaeological sites
simply reflects the fact that most desirable shoreline habitats of that age are
now deeply submerged and unavailable to study.
Session: Investigating Resource Use
Thursday, May 8, 2003
9:00 am – 11:50 am
Session Chair:
Papers: 7
Title: Cambium-Stripped Lodgepole Pine CMT Research in
Interior British Columbia: A Critical Evaluation.
Author: Simon P. Kaltenrieder and Joanne E. Hammond (Matrix Research
Ltd.)
Abstract: In the British Columbia interior, the most commonly recorded
kind of Culturally Modified Tree (CMT) is the bark-stripped lodgepole pine (Pinus
contorta var. latifolia Douglas ex Loud.). These CMTs represent
traditional aboriginal lodgepole pine cambium harvesting. Virtually
ignored by archaeologists until the 1980s, bark-stripped lodgepole pine CMTs
have since been recorded in the thousands, primarily in the course of forestry
industry related CRM assessments. We critically review the study of these
CMTs in British Columbia. We explore CMT survey and recording methods and
their underlying principles and assumptions. We evaluate the
attempts which have been made to utilize the CMT data collected thus far, and
propose alternatives to current approaches.
Title: Variability in the Use of Marine Fauna
at an Early Ceramic site, Antigua, West Indies.
Author: Christine Cluney (McMaster)
Abstract: Excavations at
Doig’s, an early Saladoid (Ceramic Age) coastal site in Antigua, West Indies
yielded a large number of fish remains. Analysis
of these remains show the extent of variability in the average size of fish over
time and space. This information is used to assess the contribution of marine
resources to the diet, the types of fishing technology involved in capture, and
whether or not Saladoid populations had a deleterious effect on fish
populations.
Title: Geological Sources and Archaeological Distributions
of Translucent Chert in New Brunswick.
Authors:
David W. Black (UNB), Susan E. Blair (UNB) and Brent D. Suttie (UNB)
Abstract: The best known source of
translucent variegated chert in New Brunswick is the Washademoak Lake Chert
Source in Queens County. However, several other sources of chert having similar
appearances are known or suspected. Here we discuss current understandings of
these geological sources. We also present preliminary analyses of spatial and
temporal distributions of translucent variegated chert in the New Brunswick
archaeological record.
Title: The Bodo Bison Skulls Site (FaOm-1):
Current Research in the Neutral Hills of Alberta.
Author:
Timothy Panas (Alberta)
Abstract: First
discovered in 1995, the Bodo Bison Skulls site (FaOm-1) represents what could be
one of the largest Late Prehistoric bison kills in western Canada. Although
significant in terms of research potential, this site is situated in the Neutral
Hills, an area that has not been investigated thoroughly in either Alberta or
Saskatchewan. This paper will
examine prehistory and history of the area through numerous background sources,
as well as provide an overview of the author’s research goals for developing a
model of the site’s usage within the larger scale of the Northern Plains.
Title: The Use of Palaeoethology as a Means of
Understanding Predator-prey Relationships and Hominid Hunting: A Crimean
Case-study.
Author: Ariane Burke (Manitoba)
Abstract: Equus hydruntinus, an
extinct species of equid, is a particularly common species of prey during the
Middle Paleolithic, particularly in the Crimean Peninsula. Despite the frequency
with which it is encountered, its systematic affiliation has long been a subject
of controversy. Recent morphometric and genetic research shows that it is a
close relative of the Asiatic ass. This information is used here to propose a
model for the social organization and behaviour of E. hydruntinus. The
possibility of using this information to reconstruct the decisions taken by
Middle Paleolithic hunters in Crimea is explored here.
Title: Species Identification of Pacific Salmon from
Archaeological Bones through
DNA Analysis.
Author: Dongya Y. Yang (SFU), Aubrey Cannon (McMaster) and Shelley R.
Saunders (McMaster)
Abstract: A DNA test was developed in this study to identify species from
archaeological salmon bones. Short fragments (less than 200bp) of mitochondrial
DNA from the control region (D‑loop) and cytochrome B were targeted for
amplification using the Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) technique. The method
was tested on more than 20 salmon bone samples (dated 6000 to 2000 BP) from the
site of Namu on the central coast of British Columbia. Four species: Coho,
Sockeye, Pink and Chum salmon were identified from the samples. The results
indicate that systematic contaminations could be excluded from the test since
multiple species were identified from the same set of extraction and similar
sequences were observed from different bone samples of the same species.
Title:
The Truth about Deer, Turtles, and Dogs: An Examination of Ancient Maya
Human-Faunal Interactions.
Author:
Lindsay Foreman (Western)
Abstract:
The lifestyle and culture of the ancient Maya of Mesoamerica have been
studied for over five centuries. However,
until the 1970s relatively little attention was devoted to the systematic
collection and analysis of faunal remains recovered during the archaeological
excavations of Maya sites. This
paper focuses on the interactions between the ancient Maya and three animal
types: deer, turtle, and dog. Maya
codices, ritual books, ceramics and artwork, ethnohistoric accounts and evidence
from the archaeological record illustrate the symbolic, ritual, and ceremonial
significance of these animals in the Maya world and provide information on the
ancient methods of procurement and processing and the role of deer, turtles, and
dogs in the subsistence economy of the ancient Maya.
Minimum number of individual (MNI) and number of individual specimen (NISP)
data were collected for these three animal types from six inland and four
coastal lowland sites from the Preclassic to the Postclassic periods.
Chi-square contingency analyses of these data illustrate an association
between the spatial and temporal distribution of deer, turtle, and dog in the
Maya realm. Further analyses using
one-dimensional chi-square tests provide evidence of changing frequencies of
deer, turtles, and dogs within inland and coastal regions and during the three
temporal periods at the α=0.05 significance level.
Thursday, May 8, 2003.
4:20 pm – 5:00 pm
Session Chair:
Papers: 2
Title: Basement Archaeology: The Coal Cellar / Wine Cellar in Calgary’s
Lougheed Mansion.
Author: Dale Elizabeth Boland
(Calgary)
Abstract: Built in 1891, Beaulieu (the
Lougheed Mansion) was the impressive home of Senator Lougheed and family, and,
after the Depression, housed the Canadian Women’s Army Corps and the Red
Cross. The University of Calgary’s Programme for Public Archaeology was invited to partake in the
current large-scale renovation project and particularly to investigate a story
about the destruction of the wine cellar in the late 1940s. This paper presents
the findings from these excavations; evidence of the varying functions of the
basement space will be detailed in an effort to understand household activities
during the early part of Calgary’s history.
Author:
Ken Cassavoy (Trent)
Affiliation: Trent University
Abstract: In the spring of 2001, low Lake Huron water levels and
a severe ice scour, revealed several ship frames (ribs) sticking up out of the
beach sand at Southampton, Ontario. An
archaeological crew, operating under a provincial licence and led by Marine
Archaeologist Ken Cassavoy, carried out two short excavations at the site in
2001 and 2002 which revealed the presence of not one but two shipwrecks buried
under the sand. One wreck is a
small work barge probably built in the 1870's and used in construction of the
harbour of refuge at Southampton. The
other may be the earliest shipwreck ever found on the upper lakes. It is a small schooner with construction features which
indicate a probable building date during the late 1700's. A rare find on the schooner is a swivel-cannon which has been
dated, through parallels, to the late 18th or early 19th
century. Archival research
has identified a strong candidate for the vessel's identity - The Weasel built
in 1786 in Detroit. A full
excavation of the schooner site is planned for the spring of 2004.
Session: Archaeological
Research at National Historic Sites of Canada
Friday, May 9, 2003
9:00 am – 11:10 am
Organizers: Jim Molnar and
Christophe Rivet (Parks Canada)
Papers: 5
Session Abstract: Canada has a system of 884 designated National Historic
Sites spread across the country, representing many themes of Canadian history.
Most of these sites have archaeological resources that are time capsules of our
country's
history. This session presents recent archaeological researches at a
number of sites that showcase the best of archaeologists' abilities to
understand, protect and present this history.
Title: A Team Effort: The Prince of Wales Fort Stabilization Project.
Author: Sandra Santesso (Parks Canada)
Abstract: The Prince of Wales Fort in
northern Manitoba served as a fortified post for the Hudson's Bay Company during
a period of intense conflict between the English and French. Destroyed by
the French in 1783, it was never reoccupied. Between 1934 and 1960 Parks
Canada repaired and rebuilt sections of the Fort. Now, some 50 years
later, the Fort is under siege again -- this time by the ravages of time and
water. To save the walls of Prince
of Wales Fort from further deterioration, Parks Canada created a
multidisciplinary team of historians, engineers and archaeologists.
Our cooperative relationship proved beneficial to all the disciplines
involved. But more important, the team approach significantly benefited
the National Historic Site. The
involvement of Archaeological Services led to exciting discoveries of artifacts
and features where historical documentation suggested that little would be
found. Based on the data that the historians and archaeologists provided,
the engineers can now create stabilization proposals that will help save the
Fort's walls, while respecting the historic site's integrity and remaining
sensitive to buried cultural material.
Title: Research
and Management Issues Concerning Burial Grounds at Fur Trade National Historic
Sites: The Case of Rocky Mountain House.
Authors: Peter D. Francis and John E.P. Porter (Parks Canada)
Abstract: Burial grounds associated with
fur trade posts in western Canada have been identified both in the historical
record and by archaeological investigation at several National Historic Sites
managed by Parks Canada. For example, locations of discrete burial grounds
are known at Fort St. James and Fort Langley in British Columbia and Jasper
House and Rocky Mountain House in Alberta. There are research concerns and
issues of cultural resource management common to all of these sites. These
are identified and discussed in this paper. Each site, however, gives rise
to particular concerns, and this paper will focus on management issues arising
from the Fur Trade Era burials at Rocky Mountain House National Historic Site of
Canada. Significant cultural resource issues include the extent of the
known burial ground and the possibility of additional burial areas within the
boundaries of the National Historic Site. These research and management
issues take on increased importance when combined with Aboriginal concerns as
well as development pressures from the oil and gas industry, which
shares a portion of the national historic site.
Title: The Archaeology of Place: 5000 Years of Human Occupation of Port au
Choix.
Author: M.A.P. Renouf (MUN)
Abstract: This paper highlights 5000 years
of human occupation of Port au Choix, including Amerindian, Palaeoeskimo,
European and Euro-Canadian occupations. Research
emphasis has been on how these different cultures adapted to the
changing environment, and results have shown different and similar adaptive
strategies.
Title: Re-interpretation of a National Historic Site through Archaeology.
Author: Bill Nesbitt (Dundurn National Historic Site)
Abstract: Dundurn Castle has operated as a public museum since 1900 and
as an historic house since 1965. An on-going programme of building and
landscape restoration, begun in 1990, has always included "leisurely"
mitigation, and research based archaeology. These activities have greatly
informed, and in some cases radically altered, the interpretation and
re-development of the site.
Title of Presentation: Landscapes of Power: Fulford Place,
Brockville and the Olmsteds
Author: Dena Doroszenko (Ontario Heritage Foundation)
Abstract: By the time Senator George Fulford I built Fulford Place in
Brockville, Ontario, the Thousand Islands region was well on its way to becoming
a tourist resort heralded as "The Venice of America" because it was
situated on a series of islands connected by a joint waterway. Fulford took
property he already owned, property whose characteristics already identified him
as a member of the local elite and completely reshaped it. Fulford Place was the
creation of its owner, George Fulford I, and its professional designers.
However, Fulford clearly identified and orchestrated to a degree the
construction of Fulford Place to fulfil his ambitions and dreams. Since
Fulford's initial goal was to rework his Brockville estate through the
improvement of the landscape and re-orientation of the property from the water,
Fulford first contacted the American landscape firm of Olmsted brothers in 1896.
Archaeological investigations at Fulford Place have been minimal to date
primarily due to the amount of landfill terracing undertaken during the
construction phase of Fulford Place, as designed by the Olmsteds. In 2002,
planned restoration of the formal garden, designed by the Olmsted Brothers firm,
led to a project in this area in August. The results of this project will be
discussed in this paper.
Session: Gender and Agency in Hunter-Gatherer Archaeology
Friday, May 9, 2003.
9:00 am – 11:50 am
Organizer: Sarah Bonesteel
Papers: 7
Title: Gender Role Flexibility and
Social Agency in Early Palaeoeskimo Archaeology.
Author: Sarah Bonesteel (McMaster)
Abstract: Archaeologists have identified a
spatial separation of artifacts attributed to women and men’s tasks within
early Palaeoeskimo structural remains, and have speculated that work areas were
also gender separated. A critical examination of site data shows less pronounced
patterning in artifact distribution. This suggests the possible flexibility of
gender roles and the degree of social agency exercised in early Palaeoeskimo
culture, and points to the need for a more developed program of research to
evaluate these issues.
Title: Lithic Technology, Agency, and the Pre-Dorset:
Inferring Changes in Social Organization Through Raw Material Procurement
Strategies.
Author: S. Brooke Milne (McMaster)
Abstract:
Author: Meghan Burchell (McMaster)
Abstract: I have applied a contextual
analysis to the mortuary data of the Northwest Coast between ca.6000-1000 BP to
show that there are visible temporal and spatial patterns relating to the ways
males and females are represented in burials.
I have collected a total of 1039 individuals from 44 burials sites from
the north, south and central regions of the coast. I examined variables including:
burial mode; position of the body; type of interment and the types of
grave goods in relation to gender and age groups. The differences between male and female burials are most
reflected by the type of grave good(s) and the frequency and type of interment.
Although there is no patterning among the burials from the Northwest
Coast as a whole, gender-based difference in mortuary treatment are clearly
evident within and between regions.
Title: Thule Cyborgs and Dorset Chimeras: On the Varieties
of Hybrid Agency in Arctic Prehistory.
Author: Peter Whitridge (MUN)
Abstract: Recent archaeological approaches to agency tend to situate the
capacity to act in individuals. Although the autonomy of social actors might
vary depending on their position and roles within a larger system or field of
interacting individuals, such “classic human agents” end at the skin.
Actor-network theory offers an alternative model of agency as an effect of much
messier, heterogeneous assemblages of human and non-human actors. Agency is
distributed across profoundly hybrid networks that consist of concrete things,
such as embodied individuals, artifacts, architecture, animals, and topography,
as well as less tangible entities, such as ideas, symbols, technical knowledge,
memories, and other imaginaries. From this perspective, archaeological
investigation of the agencies of women and men, young and old, elite and
commoner, must address the ways in which human and non-human participants were
differentially enrolled in the larger or smaller hybrid networks on which every
actorial project depends. By way of archaeological illustration, significant
differences in the morphology of Thule and Dorset actor-networks are inferred,
based on the contrasting representations of humans in figurative art, and
markedly different technological styles. These differences in turn hold
interesting implications for the differential agencies of women and men in the
respective cultural contexts
Title: Engendering Socioeconomy on the British Columbia
Plateau: A Study from the Keatley Creek Site.
Author: Natasha Lyons (Parks Canada) and
William C. Prentiss (Montana)
Abstract: A revised chronology for the
Keatley Creek site on the British Columbia Plateau has brought to light changes
in socioeconomic patterns over several millennia of site residence.
Site use opens as early as 2800 B.P. with fairly limited occupations of
small housepits, and transforms through a sequence of growth and consolidation
to an aggregated village around 1700 B.P. Occupation
of this village may have been attended by sharp increases in population and
changes in social organization and economic pursuits, while its abandonment,
occurring ca. 800 B.P., may be related to local catastrophes and/or regional
climatic factors. This phase is followed by later smaller-scale reoccupations.
In this paper, the Keatley Creek chronology is examined using new stratigraphic
data in concordance with floral and faunal evidence. These various lines of data
indicate a shift in food preparation contexts around 1350 B.P., potentially
associated with resource intensification processes in the broader region. The
paper explores some of the gender implications resonant in these lines of data
and speculates on processes that may be involved in this shift. The evidence
portrays one aspect of the larger socioeconomic processes at work on the
Canadian Plateau in the late prehistoric, related to the rise of societal
complexity.
Title: Structure through Agency: Tsimshian
Plant Use in the Contact Transition.
Author: Andrew Martindale (McMaster)
and Sarah Donnelly (McMaster)
Abstract: Seed
remains are among the most abundant food resources recovered from late contact
and post-contact archaeological sites in Tsimshian territory. In this
paper we examine how plant use activity areas demonstrate the continued
significance of plant foods in the Tsimshian diet through the contact era. Reconstructions
of the location and degree of use of these features indicate that
plant-processing and consumption activities reflected socio-economic relations
within Tsimshian communities. We argue that the traditional subsistence economy
was a source of indigenous economic autonomy after the advent of the European
market economy. Since ethnographic and
ethnohistoric data indicate that plant resources were owned and controlled by
Tsimshian women, these data comment on the nature of Tsimshian gender relations
and their stability through the contact period.
Author: Minako
Togawa (McGill)
Abstract: Jomon clay figurines, which are human representations,
had been produced throughout the Jomon period (13,000-2,300 bp).
I will discuss in detail a case of the Kaminabe site, Kumamoto.
A large number of clay figurines were recovered from this site for a
brief period toward the end of the Jomon period.
This paper will attempt to explore the sudden increase of the figurines
in the contexts of increasing reliance on cultivation and women’s role in this
subsistence shift.
Session: Method and Theory I
Friday, May 9, 2003.
9:00 am – 11:50 am
Session Chair:
Papers: 7
Title:
Correlations between Catastrophic Paleoenvironmental Events and Native Oral
Traditions of the Pacific Northwest.
Author: Rick Budhwa (Wet’suwet’en
Lands and Resources)
The indigenous populations of the Pacific Northwest have
consistently maintained that proof of their long occupation in their traditional
ethnographic territories is embedded in their oral traditions.
Native groups claim that information within their oral traditions is
historically accurate. Therefore, one may presume that a comparison between oral
traditions and scientifically known prehistoric events would lead to similar
interpretations. Past catastrophic
environmental events (such as volcanic eruptions, earthquakes, landslides,
tsunamis, floods, etc) with discrete, recognizable attributes, may serve as
benchmarks for comparison to prehistoric references contained within oral
traditions. For the most part,
geologists have provided us with a specific range of dates and magnitudes for
such events. The historical
literature pertaining to such groups (specific to each event) is reviewed for
oral traditions that may refer to the event in question.
Through the use of qualitative tables, relationships between the
geological and archaeological evidence and the event depicted in the oral
tradition are shown to exist. Moreover,
a ‘qualitative’ measure is employed in a descriptive fashion, where a
distinction is made between clear relationships and less obvious ones. Perhaps
such an evaluation of a portion of the indigenous perspective within a western
scientific framework may serve as a foundation for further work in this area.
Eventually, a combination of the two perspectives may yield a richer,
more holistic view of the past.
Title: Useful Archaeological
Websites: Developing Web-based Tools and Databases for Archaeological Analysis.
Author: Darren Shaw (Alberta)
Abstract: The web is an excellent
medium to present archaeological information, but it is seldom used to its full
potential. By integrating databases into Web sites, archaeological,
photographic, GIS, and bibliographic data are tied into a coherent system that
can be accessed at any time from anywhere in the world. With integrated online
databases, a simple mouse click will carry you between data sets to analytical
tools in order to answer research questions quickly and easily. In this
discussion I will present the online databases and analytical tools developed
for the Baikal Archaeology Project, and describe the tools and techniques used
to create these online systems.
Title: The Draper Site Village Expansion Sequence: 3-D
Virtual Modelling
and Animations in Archaeological Interpretation.
Author: William D. Finlayson (Laurier) and Rick Fischer (CMC)
Abstract: The Draper site is a 3 hectare prehistoric Huron village that
was uncovered through rescue excavation by Finlayson on contract to the
Archaeological Survey of Canada, Canadian Museum of Civilization in 1975 and
1978. Excavations revealed that Draper began as a small village of seven
houses on 1.2 hectares of land occupied by about 400 Huron; it expanded 5 times
to become a very large village of 37 houses on 3.4 hectares of land occupied be
an estimated 2000 people. After more than 25 years, Draper remains one of
the most complex Iroquoian villages ever excavated. Over the years, various
plans and artist's reconstructions of the village have been used to disseminate
information on its complex history. None however, were able to take
advantage of the modern technology that is at our disposal today. In 1998,
Toronto-based, free-lance computer illustrator Rick Fischer approached Finlayson
about using 3-dimensional computer graphics to create a native village;
Finlayson suggested the various expansions at the Draper site as the subject for
a computer-based reconstruction and animation. This presentation shows the
first portion of the animation created by Fisher in consultation with Finlayson.
It also presents a new interpretation on the sequence of expansions which was
developed as work on the animation proceeded, and demonstrates how the use of 3-
D modeling can offer an alternative focus for archaeological interpretation.
Title: Treatment of Low Potential Areas in Predictive
Models used in the Northern Alberta Oil Sands Region.
Author: Tara Bond (Alberta)
Abstract: Increased resource development in
the forestry, oil, and gas industries has stimulated archaeological survey over
large areas of land. These intense
developments have spawned new methods of surveying large areas of land quickly
and economically such as predictive modeling.
Predictive models attempt to describe trends in archaeological site
location and, thereby, estimate areas of high potential.
Their success rate will ultimately determine the rescue of archaeological
resources. Predictive models are
often used as pre-field sampling strategies, as well as a means to justify the
disregard of low potential areas. Many
of these models rely on GIS, despite its limitations. This has led to these models being used as a tool to
digitally represent the experience of an archaeologist, which reinforces
regional biases. By reinforcing the
regional biases, low potential areas remain uncontested because the models are
designed to represent areas where previous sites have been found.
This study measures the areas that have been surveyed since 1980 in the
Northern Alberta Oil Sands region and shows that low potential areas may be the
result of compounding surveying biases with predictive models.
Title: From Canadian Oil-fields to Archaeology: Seismic
Tomography, a
Future Tool of Archaeological Investigation.
Author: Claire Allum (Bowdoin)
Abstract: Geophysicists from the University of Calgary have been working
with Canadian and US archaeologists to refine geophysical prospecting
techniques, used by the oil and gas industry of Alberta, for archaeological
applications. In the search for oil, seismic tomography is used to explore deep
subsurface structures. In 2000, 2001, and 2002, researchers produced shallow
seismic images of Maya pyramid structures and plaza areas in northwestern Belize
demonstrating that, as techniques improve, shallow seismic imaging may be used
to locate buried architectural features within mounds or below ground surface
beyond the reach of other shallow remote-sensing devices.
Title: Developing and Implementing Heritage Management
Tools for Industrial Use in Alberta
Authors: Terrance H. Gibson (AWH), Darryl
Bereziuk (AWH), Katherine Beames (AWH)
Abstract: Alberta Western Heritage (AWH)
has developed a series of historical databases and related terrain-based
heritage potential classification models for use by the oil and gas and forest
industries in the province of Alberta. These
tools are GIS-based, and make use of a variety of “off the shelf” data
sources, including digital elevation (DEM) data, hydrology, LandSat 7 imagery and the provincial
archaeological site inventory, as
well as custom-derived data related to historical occupation of the region.
Although in themselves the tools generate interesting information, they
only become useful for land managers if they are bundled with an integrative
methodology that first standardizes forecasted ground impacts and then
calculates the probability that an historical resources site will be present at
locations that exhibit a strong likelihood to be disturbed or destroyed.
This unification is provided by AWH’s CRIMP (Cultural Resources Impact
Management Planning) process, that allows large scale land managers to determine
what effect proposed developments will have on known and potential historical
resources in a location, what mitigative action must be undertaken, and when in
the planning cycle these requirements must be fulfilled. As such, the CRIMP
process provides a useful management platform from which industrial personnel
can plan their operations in order to minimize potential impact to historical
resource sites and reduce associated field survey costs related to regulatory
compliance requirements. The CRIMP process is now used by various developers to
manage historical resources across over 40 percent of the province.
This paper discusses how CRIMP tools are assembled, how they are used and
provides examples of where and to what success they have been applied.
Friday, May 9, 2003
9:00 am – 10:50 am
Organizer: Tracy Rogers (Toronto)
Papers: 4
Session Abstract: The field of forensic
anthropology has evolved from the simple application of physical anthropological
techniques in skeletons of forensic interest, to complete participation in the
case. Forensic anthropologists are
trained and educated in the procedures of: (1) crime scene investigation,
including establishing appropriate boundaries, proper evidence recovery, chain
of custody, etc.; (2) searching and recovering human remains, including
perpetrator behaviour, animal activity, environmental movement, normal
disarticulation sequences, visual indicators of primary and secondary scenes,
recognition of clandestine burials and body dumpsites, systematic search
protocols, mapping, excavation, etc.; (3) scene interpretation, including the
body-grave interface; (4) the analysis of human remains in a forensic context,
including the biological profile, personal identification, health and trauma
analysis; (5) the presentation of evidence in court. In Canada, forensic anthropology is a forensic science that
incorporates aspects of biological anthropology, archaeology, cultural
anthropology, and criminalistics. There
is no artificial division of the case into field and lab components.
This session outlines the use of archaeological and skeletal analyses in
the investigation and interpretation of outdoor crime scenes.
Archaeologists with an interest in forensic science are encouraged to
broaden their training to incorporate forensic, lab and court theoretical and
methodological concerns.
Author: Tracy Rogers (Toronto)
Abstract: This paper outlines the role of
archaeology in forensic anthropology, addressing the ideological differences
between the Canadian and British approaches to the discipline.
Emphasis is on the relationship between field and lab work, the
importance of context in the interpretation of skeletal remains, and the
importance of forensic anthropological knowledge during search and recovery of
human remains, and site interpretation.
Title: The Importance of Context and Analysis during the
Recovery of Human Remains.
Author: Christian Crowder (Toronto)
Abstract: In some jurisdictions, human
remains from outdoor crime scenes are recovered by one specialist and examined
by another. This approach treats
the grave and the remains as separate entities and their analysis and
interpretation as distinct processes that have nothing to contribute to one
another. Complete knowledge of the body-grave relationship is important for
proper interpretation of the scene, and preventing potential errors or
difficulties in analysis of the remains. This case report presents a complex
crime scene in which the buried remains endured multiple disturbances from the
time of deposition to recovery. Carnivore scavenging partially disinterred the
remains; however, the pattern of elements present and missing was odd,
suggesting selective removal of elements. Undergarments demonstrated advanced
decomposition that would not be expected in remains that had been buried between
one to two years. Soil testing and law enforcement questioning discovered that a
corrosive had been used to destroy evidence. As a result of the preliminary
evaluation of trace and biological evidence at the crime scene, law enforcement
was better able to focus their interrogation of the suspects, leading to a quick
confession. This case demonstrates the necessity of involving the forensic
specialist in all stages of body recovery and analysis.
Author: Greg Olson (York Regional Police)
Abstract: Since the beginning of time, the
criminal element has been inventing ways to disguise its crimes. It has been the
role of police agencies around the world to investigate crimes by deduction and
now by way of science. One such science is that of archaeology, the science of
antiquities; one which investigates the histories of peoples by the remains
of earlier periods. Badly mismanaged scenes have placed great pressure on law
enforcement agencies to develop expertise in the area of human remains;
location, identification and removal. The principles of archaeology have a
logical application to the area of police work and the diverse scenes processed
by officers. The York Regional Police have formed the first Archaeological
Forensic Recovery Team in Canada, a team comprised entirely of police officers.
The officers involved in the team are trained in archaeological methods along
with osteology, entomology and forensic anthropology. The team members
successfully blend investigative and evidence handling skills with forensic
science to create a unique "hybrid" criminal investigator.
This approach has been used by the team at homicide scenes, robberies,
sexual assault cases and other types of crime sites that require a systematic
grid search.
Title: The Use of Archaeological Techniques in Underwater
Crime Scene Investigation.
Author: Stephen Henkel (Toronto Police
Marine Unit)
Abstract: The purpose of this paper is to
outline the use of underwater archaeological techniques in the investigation of
underwater crime scenes and body recovery missions. Topics covered include:
an introduction to the Toronto Police Underwater Recovery Team, the importance
of proper documentation of underwater scenes and complete recovery of evidence,
the use of techniques borrowed from archaeology, the limitations of underwater
archaeological techniques in this context (visibility), goals of investigation
(recovery & interpretation), future trends (privatization &
contracting), roles for archaeologists?
Session: The Application of Archaeological Data/Methods to Modern
Environmental Problems
Friday, May 9, 2003
9:00 am – 11:30 am
Organizers: Maribeth Murray (Alaska) and Jeannette Smith
(Alaska)
Papers: 6
Session Abstract: Archaeological data and methods
play an increasingly important role in the
understanding of present environmental issues, and in the modeling of future
scenarios. In many situations, contemporary social and biophysical responses to
land-use, pollutants, resource utilization and spatial organization, to name but
a few, have informing analogues recorded in past cultural and environmental
sequences. Papers in this session will explore how these analogues are obtained,
and how they are used and potentially misused in the context of modern
environmental problems and policies.
Title:
Tracing Sustainable Land Management Strategies in Semi-Arid Southern Africa.
Author: Jeannette Smith (Alaska)
Abstract: Semi-arid regions of southern
Africa have a long history of sustainable agropastoral land use, and yet the
majority of policy makers and conservationists over look the strategies and
lessons that may be extracted from the study of these historical patterns. In an
attempt to address this bias, a model of shifting sustainability, derived from
archaeological sequences spanning the last 1200 years in the Shashe/Limpopo
River Basin region of southern Africa, is presented here. Climatic
reconstruction indicates that through out this period the region has been
semi-arid with variable annual precipitation, while in contrast, archaeological
evidence shows that the region has been able to support large-scale agropastoral
production, and complex societies that participated in international trade. This
paper presents a series of agropastoral strategies, and social and economic
networks employed to offset climatic variability and sustain occupation in the
region.
Abstract: The stable isotope signatures of
biologic organisms recovered from archaeological sites offer excellent data on
past environmental and ecological conditions. Coastal sites contain
well-preserved archaeofauna and abundant deposits of marine shellfish. Stable
carbon and nitrogen isotopes (d13C and d15N) derived from
bone collagen provide information about changes in food web dynamics, and
productivity levels, and thus ecosystem changes. Recent work indicates that d13C
is strongly controlled by the photosynthetic rate in phytoplankton and differing
ocean productivity regimes. These findings provide a mechanism for linking d13C
values and the magnitude of primary production. Any changes in the length of the
marine food web induced by climate change or food web interactions will be
exhibited in the d15N in the bone collagen of marine vertebrates.
Stable oxygen isotopes (d18O) and Mg/Ca ratios of marine mollusks and
microfossil assemblages in sediment cores provide information on changes in
ocean temperature and salinity. Factors other than temperature have little
influence on skeletal Mg/Ca ratios while d18O varies with both
salinity and temperature. All of these analyses in combination provide a picture
of ocean and atmospheric climate change.
Title: Assessing Mercury Levels in Ancient and Modern
Alaskan Caribou: Implications for Community and Ecosystem Health.
Authors: S. Craig Gerlach, Lawrence K.
Duffy, and Maribeth S. Murray (Alaska)
Abstract: At present, there is little
information about the processes and pathways related to mercury accumulation in
Arctic and sub-Arctic coastal and terrestrial ecosystems. Caribou are typically
associated with the tundra biome where they graze on low-growing plants such as
lichen, sedge, and cotton grass. Changes in past contaminant levels in these
plants may be indexed by measuring the mercury concentrations in caribou
tissues, fur, and bones. In this study, northwestern Alaska caribou bone
fragments from archaeological sites dating to approximately 100 years B.P.
showed detectable mercury and methylmercury levels. As the sample sizes in our
study are still small, with large standard deviations, conclusions are
provisional. However, we now know that archaeological bone is amenable to this
type of analysis, and can further explore long-term and present day community
and ecosystem health through this venue.
Title:
Wood Use in the Arctic: Driftwood Past and Present.
Author: Claire Alix
(Alaska/Sorbonne)
Abstract:
Previous analysis
of wooden remains from coastal arctic archaeological sites has raised the
question of how much choice coastal carvers were able to exercise when selecting
wood for their work. This, in turn,
has posed the question of driftwood abundance and composition. The problem, then, is to elaborate the necessary tools and
build the reference data that would enable archaeologists to reconstruct the
environmental, technological, cultural and eventually social framework of wood
use. Environmental change, as it
relates to driftwood and its use, and as evidenced in the archaeological and
oral history record of Alaska is an important element in the overall picture.
The consequences of climatic change on driftwood are intermingled with
those of cultural but also technological changes the people and their
environment have experienced in the last 100 years.
This paper presents how analyses of driftwood data from the past and the
present each allows the other to explore the mechanisms of its “production”
and its use.
Title: On the Use of Historical Proxies in Wildlife
Management and Conservation Biology in Alaska and Canada.
Author: S. Craig Gerlach (Alaska)
Abstract: Sources of historical information that commonly serve
retrospective analyses are becoming more important in the resolution of debates
in wildlife management, conservation and biology. Archaeology, paleontology,
chronometric dating, oral sources and documentary records provide just a few
examples of the kinds of information that wildlife managers find useful for
understanding of the historical and ecological dimensions of human-wildlife
interactions over variable periods of time.
With an example drawn from the Yukon flats of interior Alaska, Yukon, and
the Northwest Territories (NT), and with a summary of how various historical
records are used and evaluated, this paper discusses the data sets used to
demonstrate that Wood Bison (Bison bison athabascae) were an important
subsistence resource for Athabaskans until possibly as late as the 1800’s,
that the historic distribution of this species was considerably more extensive
than once thought, and that Wood Bison were a keystone species in Alaska, Yukon,
and the NT until possible as recently as the turn of the 20th
century. The use of historical records in the continuing Wood Bison debate will
also be discussed in relation to the style and debate tactics of federal
wildlife managers, and, alternatively, in a context of common-sense and good use
of science and history to resolve wildlife management disputes.
Title: Participants' Experiences with Heritage
Conservation: Creating and Implementing Archaeological Master Plans in Mid-sized
Ontario Municipalities
Author: Catherine Beck (Waterloo)
Abstract:
Session: Archaeology at Port au Choix, Northwestern
Newfoundland
Saturday, May 10, 2003.
9:00 am – 2:30 pm
Session Organizers: M.A.P.
Renouf (MUN) and Patricia J. Wells (MUN)
Papers: 10
Session
Abstract
Port au Choix, northwestern
Newfoundland, was a major focus of occupation for two Amerindian and two
Palaeoeskimo cultures. This session presents and summarizes results of some of
the many faculty and student research projects that have been carried out at
Port au Choix over the past twenty years. The
chronological range is 5500 - 800 BP and the cultures covered include Maritime
Archaic, Groswater Palaeoeskimo, Dorset Palaeoeskimo and Recent Indian.
This sequence of cultural occupations is put in palaeo-environmental
context.
Title: Seventy-Five Years of
Archaeological Research at Port au Choix.
Author: M.A.P. Renouf (MUN)
Abstract: Port au Choix has long been a central place for
populations living on the Northern Peninsula of Newfoundland and consequently is
archaeological very rich, with a prehistory known to extend between 5500 and 800
years ago. Over the past 75 years
several archaeologists have made Port au Choix a focus of their research, each
addressing outstanding research problems of their day.
This paper introduces the lineage of Port au Choix researchers, and
reviews their research objectives and results.
Seventy-five years later, what is the future of Port au Choix’s past?
Title: Environmental Context
and Impacts of Prehistoric Occupation at Port au Choix, Northwest Newfoundland.
Author: Trevor Bell, Joyce Macpherson, M.A.P. Renouf (MUN)
Abstract: Two of the goals of the Port au Choix Archaeology and
Landscape History Project are (1) to understand the prehistoric occupation of
the region in the context of landscape and climate change, and (2) to examine
the potential impact of occupation on the environment, with particular emphasis
on vegetation and landscape stability. Together with collaborators we have
assembled a diverse data set to study human-environment relationships. The
primary data include: pollen, midges, diatoms, charcoal, spores and grain-size
from pond sediments; pollen, macro-fossils and charcoal from peat; radiocarbon
dates; and archaeological data. Preliminary
results suggest a close correspondence between climate and the changing cultural
record at Port au Choix, as well as a significant impact on local boreal
vegetation and environment by hunter-gatherer groups.
Title: A Study of Maritime
Archaic Sites from the Strait of Belle Isle and Great Northern Peninsula,
Newfoundland and Labrador.
Author: Heather Reid (MUN)
Abstract: This paper summarizes a comparative study of Maritime
Archaic habitation sites located in the Strait of Belle Isle and Great Northern
Peninsula, dating from 5500 - 3200 BP, and including material from the Gould
site (EeBi-42) at Port au Choix. The
artifacts associated with these sites all have characteristics affiliated with a
southern variant of the Maritime Archaic, believed to have co-existed in
Newfoundland and Labrador with a northern variant that dates from 7500 BP - 3500
BP. This paper presents a typology for the Maritime Archaic from this geographic
area and time period, primarily consisting of side-notched, expanding based
bifaces, non-hafted bifaces, and flake tools.
The study also shows that the types of artifacts and lithic raw materials
found in these sites do not vary greatly over the geographic area or time
period. Furthermore, similarity of
artifact type and raw material between these sites and Area 10 of the L’anse
Amour site (EiBf-4) in Labrador, dated to 6435±95 BP (SI-2305), suggests that
the southern variant of the Maritime Archaic may have co-existed with the
northern variant for some 3000 years.
Title: Mobility, Exchange,
and Curation as Factors in the Distribution of the Phillip’s Garden West
Toolkit.
Author: Karen Ryan (Toronto)
Abstract: This paper briefly reviews the attributes and
chronological position of the Groswater Phillip’s Garden West (PGW) toolkit
before focussing on the geographic distribution of these distinctive lithic
artefacts. Identified only on the island of Newfoundland, the majority of these
exceptionally finely crafted specimens are found at sites within the Port au
Choix area, while the remaining artefacts occur (typically as isolated finds) at
palaeoeskimo sites throughout the island. The primary goal of this paper is to
re-examine the distribution of PGW tools in order to offer an explanation for
how and why elements of this toolkit occurred outside the Port au Choix region.
Title: An Analysis of Faunal Remains from Two Groswater
Palaeoeskimo Sites at Port au Choix.
Author: Patricia J. Wells (MUN)
Abstract: An analysis of faunal material from two Groswater
Palaeoeskimo sites, Phillip’s Garden East (EeBi-1) and Phillip’s Garden West
(EeBi-11) on the Point Riche peninsula, Port au Choix, was undertaken to compare
the economic activities engaged in by the occupants of the two sites.
This is particularly relevant as there are demonstrated morphological
differences in the tool types seen at Phillip’s Garden West.
The results of this analysis demonstrate that the relative frequency of
species and the seasonality are similar for both sites, with a primary emphasis
on late winter harp seal hunting. Nevertheless,
the body part frequency of the seal bones suggests differences in the treatment
of this animal at the two sites. A
number of suggestions are explored to explain this variation. It is likely that the occupants of the two sites were in
contact, and that processing was to some extent cooperative. The absence of
cranial elements from Phillip’s Garden West suggests special treatment of the
seal body that could have an ideological aspect.
Title: The Changing Nature and Function of Phillip's
Garden: Diachronic Perspectives from a Dorset Palaeoeskimo Site in Port au Choix.
Author: John C. Erwin (MUN)
Abstract: Evidence from Newfoundland's
largest Dorset Palaeoeskimo site is used to demonstrate the utility of a
diachronic perspective in assessing concepts of site function, spatial
patterning, house permanence, and dwelling contemporaneity at large complex
archaeological sites. Through the separation of temporal and functional strands
of evidence, this study indicates that what appears as noise when viewed
synchronically, may be the echo of the changing nature and function of the
Phillip's Garden over time.
Title: Skeletal Age, Stage of
Life, and Patterns of Harp Seal Procurement at Phillip’s Garden: A New Look at
Some Old Bones.
Author: Maribeth S. Murray (Alaska)
Abstract: Without thin-sections of canine teeth to provide
estimates of pinniped (seals and walrus) age, skeletal age class data serves as
an effective alternative means of interpreting ancient patterns of pinniped
selection by human hunters. In this study, phocidae skeletal aging criteria (Stora
2000) are applied to previously described pinniped archaeofauna from a Dorset
Palaeoeskimo house (Feature 1) at Phillip’s Garden, Port au Choix,
Newfoundland. The pinniped remains from Feature 1, originally identified in
1991, are compared to more recently identified archaeofaunas from elsewhere in
northwestern Newfoundland and the eastern Arctic, to compare and discover
regional differences in Dorset seal procurement activities.
Title: The Recent Indian component at the Gould Site, Port
au Choix.
Author: Michael Teal,
Abstract: Recent Indian material recovered from the Gould site
(EeBi-42) in Port au Choix is presented. This
information provides new insight into the Cow Head complex (ca. 2000 - 1500 BP),
the earliest and least known cultural complex of Newfoundland’s Recent Indian
period (ca. 2000 - 650 BP). The
Gould site reveals a diverse collection of artifacts and several features which
add to our knowledge of Cow Head technology, living structures, settlement and
subsistence patterns, and cultural interaction.
Specifically, Native pottery is introduced into the Cow Head tool
assemblage, and evidence of a living structure and the use of cooking pits and
is identified. Gould site
locational data demonstrates the use of near-coastal locations by Cow Head
groups, which are hypothesized by
Rowley-Conwy (1990), Holly (1997), and Schwarz (1994) to be optimal for
procuring late fall and winter resources. Finally,
artifactual and raw material information from the Gould site further illustrates
the interaction among prehistoric Native groups throughout Atlantic Canada, and
adds tangible new evidence of Recent Indian and Dorset Palaeoeskimo interaction.
Title; Palaeoethnobotanical
Research at Port au Choix.
Author: Michael Deal (MUN)
Abstract: This paper reviews a decade of palaeoethnobotanical
research at Port au Choix. The initial work involved the laboratory analysis of
small sediment samples collected by M.A.P. Renouf from three Palaeoeskimo sites.
Since 1998, more than 200 samples have been processed from Maritime
Archaic and Recent Indian contexts at the Gould site (EeBi-42). >From these
studies, five different genera (or species) were identified at the Palaeoeskimo
sites, while the Gould site has yielded 16 genera (or species) from the Maritime
Archaic component and eight from the Recent Indian component.
Despite low recovery rates, palaeoethnobotanical sampling of prehistoric
sites at Port au Choix has produced useful information on aboriginal plant use,
site seasonality, and past site environment.
M.A.P. Renouf: Concluding
Remarks
Saturday, May 10, 2003.
9:00 am – 2:50 pm
Organizer: Andrew Martindale
Papers: 10 + discussant (Susan Jamieson, Trent)
Session Abstract:
Historical archaeology is not limited to archaeology in documentary contexts but
includes, as Matthew Johnson argues, recognition of the tensions between
material and text, history and science, narrative and evolution, and European
and Indigenous. This session represents an effort to explore these
tensions, their manifestation in archaeological method and theory, and their
effect on an understanding of the history of Indigenous communities before and
after the arrival of Europeans.
Author: Gregory G.
Monks (Manitoba)
Abstract: Archaeologists in Canada, as
elsewhere, tend to concentrate their research efforts on either the post-contact
archaeological record of North American aboriginal groups or on post-contact
European and Asian groups. Little
attention is paid to the archaeological record of aboriginal peoples during the
proto-contact period, and less is paid to the archaeology of aboriginal peoples
during the post-contact period. Data from funding agencies and refereed publications are
presented and interpreted from a critical theory perspective. It is argued that
Canadian archaeologists, despite their often good intentions, work within a
larger social and political agenda that makes invisible both aboriginal peoples
and their archaeological record after European contact.
This situation is consistent with the approach taken by the federal
government to aboriginal peoples since the late nineteenth century.
Title: From Ostentation to Frugality: Material
Dynamics in the Post-contact Era.
Author: Andrew Martindale (McMaster)
Abstract: Material
culture in post-contact Tsimshian archaeological sites follows a trend from an
early fluorescence of items of wealth and display to a later abundance of
utilitarian objects and reused material and the reemergence of traditional
technologies. This can be partly explained as a correlate of the increased
availability of mass-produced European-source objects in Tsimshian territory.
However these trends also correlate with political reorganizations in Tsimshian
society in the 19th century recorded in the Tsimshian oral record.
In the early 19th century, Tsimshian leaders gained power through
control of the supply of traded furs, creating an association between European
wealth items and political stature. By the late 19th century, the
regional political structure had collapsed and the role of leaders shifted
from controlling powerful trade networks to maintaining social cohesion.
Part of this role was to reconstruct traditional values, one of which was being
efficient with resources. The return of groundstone tools and the
emergence of broken glass tools in archaeological assemblages may be part of
this effort.
Title: Landscapes as Historical Archives for Archaeological
Research with Particular Emphasis on the World of the Nitsitapii.
Author: Gerald A. Oetelaar (Calgary)
Abstract:
Landscapes
are created by people through their experience and engagement with the world
around them and through their activities and movements on the ground. In this
world, important landmarks serve as mnemonic devices eliciting myths, oral
traditions, stories, and songs. From this perspective then, landscapes are not
only the natural and cultural features of a region but also the names, oral
traditions, and ceremonies, which establish the continuity between ancestral
beings, social groups, resources, and the land. As such, the landscape becomes
the archive for the group, one that includes not only myths but also codes of
ethical conduct toward the land, the people and the resources. This paper
illustrates how such oral traditions and place names can inform archaeological
and historical research with particular emphasis on the archive of the Nitsitapii
or Blackfoot.
Authors:
K. Brownlee, B. Hewitt, D. White, C. Meiklejohn, P. Badertscher, C. Willmott, L.
Larcombe, and R.D. Hoppa (Manitoba)
Abstract: In 1999, Manitoba Historic
Resources Branch recovered the remains of two individuals near Dauphin,
Manitoba, one from the east bank of Drifting River and other at Ochre Beach, on
Dauphin Lake. Pine Creek First Nation was contacted and an elder performed
ceremonies before removal of the burials. Two previously excavated burials, in
1938 west of Dauphin Lake and in 1966 from the Red Deer River near the
Saskatchewan border, were also analyzed as they fell in the same period.
Preliminary analysis suggests that these burials, recovered over a span of 75
years, represent a single cultural group. Further, the four individuals may be
related. Analysis of the associated artifacts suggests that these are the graves
of Ojibwa or Ottawa individuals who lived in the western interior between 1808
and 1818. Artifacts, including a
variety of silver ornaments, wampum, smoking pipes, clamshells, vermilion and
copper tinkling cones, suggest consistent cultural and mortuary practices.
Ancient DNA analysis will be used to determine if there is a genetic
relationship between them. This research, blending anthropological and
historical methods with oral history and ethnohistoric evidence, makes an
important contribution to the history of this period in west central Manitoba.
Title:
Archaeological
Correlates of Contact Period Dynamics in Gwaii Haanas National Park Reserve/Haida
Heritage Site (Southern Queen Charlotte Islands, British Columbia).
Author: Trevor J. Orchard
(Toronto)
Abstract: The European contact period in
Haida Gwaii (Queen Charlotte Islands, British Columbia), as elsewhere in North
America, was a dynamic period of changing economic adaptation and changing
settlement patterns among indigenous peoples.
European interest in obtaining sea otter furs sparked the intensive, but
relatively short-lived, maritime fur trade, which in turn led to a shift in
Haida economic focus. The potential
for gain in wealth and prestige available during the maritime fur trade
introduced further changes, while introduced diseases and increased warfare
resulted in population declines. The
changes in economy, settlement strategy, and social organization that resulted
from these factors are represented in archaeological assemblages that date to
the late pre-contact through contact periods.
This paper will explore these changes in the context of recent and
ongoing research in Gwaii Haanas, and will present some of the preliminary
results of this research.
Title:
Oral Traditions and Indigenous Archaeology: The Wet’suwet’en Cultural
Heritage Initiative.
Author:
Rick Budhwa (Wet’suwet’en Lands and Resources)
Abstract:
As with other disciplines, archaeology today is changing to keep
current with society’s demands. As
a result of recent court cases in both Canada and the United States, First
Nations groups are gaining significant influence over how anthropologists and
archaeologists study their culture and history. This is an important stage in our development as a
discipline, as archaeologists become accountable for their work to any involved
First Nations groups. Indigenous peoples have their own history and perceptions
of their place in the world, recorded and transmitted in the form of oral
traditions. These oral traditions
often record the epistemology of a group, in addition to their interactions with
past peoples and the environment. They
are as real and accepted by traditional First Nations peoples as science is to
the modern western scientific community. However,
it can be argued that their past is not really “theirs”, in the sense that
their history now has been recreated by outsiders with little or no knowledge of
indigenous culture – or worse, with no desire to acquire or understand
indigenous culture. As a result, the Wet'suwet'en have taken a proactive
approach to managing their own archaeological concerns, and their basis for
territorial management of cultural heritage lies in their oral traditions.
The Wet'suwet'en Territorial Stewardship Plan is unique as it is based on the
vision of Wet'suwet'en chiefs and clan membership. It is currently
capturing the attention of industry and government alike. They are one of
the only First Nations that are presently involved in such management practices.
Author:
William A. Fox (Canadian Museum of Civilization)
Abstract: Two native copper axes were
recovered by looters of an Historic Neutral Iroquoian cemetery near Niagara
Falls, Ontario, during the early 20th century. These specimens are
described and compared to similar axes/celts and plates from Mississippian sites
in the southeastern United States. Archaeological constructs and ethnographic
information from the latter region are considered in an attempt to understand
the cultural significance of these unique Ontario artifacts.
Title: Aboriginal Trail Networks of the Central Interior
Plateau, BC: Present Day Links to Prehistoric Thoroughfares.
Author: Amanda Marshall (Ecofor)
Abstract: In the Fort St. James Forest
District, in the central interior of northern British Columbia, increased
awareness of aboriginal heritage trails has rendered a lack of concurrence with
regards to the interpretations of trails and the collaborative management of
them. During the pre-contact and
historic periods in BC, trails formed the travel and communication networks of a
region; allowing people to travel, trade, interact, and access hunting, fishing,
trapping and gathering areas. Over
the years, trail features have been commonly missed or overlooked by
archaeologists, and those that have been discovered have been under-rated in
terms of significance. This has
resulted in tensions between archaeologists, first nations, licensees, public,
and government. Tensions are
strained with regards to the designation of trails as being aboriginal vs.
European, even though in many cases aboriginal oral historical knowledge exists
for most. Even though the
importance of trails is now recognized by the provincial government in terms of
their role in aboriginal hunter-gatherer societies, the emphasis is placed on
importance and attention is only paid to historical trails of high significance,
or prehistoric trails pre-dating 1846. This
paper will look at management options with regards to trails, ground truthing
techniques and recording, as well as an accurate description of trails and trail
typologies is discussed.
Title: Historical
Archaeology of the Six Nations of the Grand River.
Author:
Gary Warrick (Laurier)
Abstract: Davisville was a Mohawk/ Mississauga community located
on the Grand River, Brantford, Ontario and occupied in the early nineteenth
century. Its archaeological remains have been located and are represented by
three cabin sites. One of these cabin sites, Davisville 2, was partially
excavated between 2000 and 2002. This paper examines the archaeological patterns
from this cabin site and compares them to archaeological signatures from other
Six Nations sites of the early nineteenth century. It will be argued that Six
Nations people resisted the colonial efforts of the British government=s Acivilization policy@, even in communities that had adopted Christianity,
participated in the fur trade and were surrounded by British settlement.
Cultural continuity in such things as regional settlement patterns, farming and
subsistence practices, and diet demonstrate remarkable conservatism with
pre-European patterns. Historical documents written by British colonial
administrators paint a different picture of Six Nations life in the early
nineteenth century. The discrepancy between the historical and archaeological
records is discussed in light of a British desire to acquire Six Nations land in
the nineteenth century.
Title: Weaving
Bead, String, Belt: Archaeology of and as Contact.
Author:
Neal Ferris (McMaster)
Abstract:
With an increasing willingness to
be more theoretically reflective, the anthropological history, or ethnohistory,
of Native contact with Europeans has begun to allow that archaeological research
may have something significant to contribute to an understanding of responses to
contact. And while past culture history approaches in archaeology tended to
offer little more than a parroting of the dependency interpretations offered by
conventional historical discussions of Native response to European contact, more
recent work has been able to build on the broader theoretical reflexive critique
in archaeology to offer much more complex and nuanced examinations of the
interaction between Native and non-Native peoples. There is a significant, even
primary role for an archaeology of the contact era that applies the interpretive
advances of the discipline, and recognises the subjectivities of history, to
reach beyond the surface story in written records and trait lists, to elucidate
the "silences" of history, and offer narratives of those events that
are not blinded by the past deterministic assumptions of dependency,
assimilation, and interpreting historically specific behaviour through the
filter of subsequent centuries of colonial impact on Native North American
communities.
Discussant: Susan Jamieson
(Trent)
Session: Method and Theory II
Saturday, May 10, 2003.
9:00 am – 11:50 am
Session Chair:
Papers: 7
Title: Why Can’t Archaeologists Agree on the Origins of
Rank Society on the Northwest Coast?
Author:
Gary Coupland (Toronto)
Abstract: Although rank society is a
fundamental feature of Northwest Coast traditional culture, archaeologists
working in the region cannot seem to agree on when the first evidence of rank
appears in the archaeological record. Suggested
dates for the first appearance of rank range from as early as 5,000 BP to within
the last 1,500 years. This paper
explores some of the reasons that lay behind this wide discrepancy.
It is argued that traditional, static theories of rank society may be an
important contributor to the disagreement among Northwest Coast archaeologist.
This disagreement will not be resolved until a more dynamic theory of
rank is embraced.
Title: Modeling Processes of Cultural Change with
Archaeological Data.
Author: Jenneth Curtis (Toronto)
Abstract: In this paper I describe the
construction of a cultural change model and the expectations derived from it in
terms of ceramic data recovered from archaeological sites.
As a case study I apply this model in an exploration of the changes
taking place across the Middle to Late Woodland transition in south-central
Ontario. The model identifies
innovation as the basis for change and postulates the communication of
innovations via social interaction as the process through which cultures change.
Central to this process are Rogers’ stages of innovation communication.
The cultural change model also incorporates various theories of cultural
change proposed in the past as potential stimuli for innovation and as means for
interaction. A series of
expectations based on this model are evaluated with respect to attribute data
recorded for Middle and early Late Woodland ceramic assemblages from the Rice
Lake-Trent River Region, Ontario. Both
attribute frequency distributions and correspondence analysis are employed to
identify patterns of continuity and change in the production of ceramic vessels.
Author: Farid Rahemtulla (UNBC)
Abstract: Analogy is a fundamental part of
the interpretive process in archaeology. Over
the last few decades there has been a great debate on the role of analogy in
archaeology, in which Alison Wylie has provided the clearest philosophical
direction. Despite this there has
been little discussion on analogical reasoning in archaeological practice.
This is a particularly critical situation at a time when the discipline
is undergoing profound conceptual shifts towards multi-vocality and the
potential inclusion of analogies drawn from different knowledge bases.
Title: Collection and Preparation of Archaeological
Materials for Ancient DNA
Analysis.
Authors: Dongya Y. Yang (SFU), Alice Storey (SFU) and Kathy Watt (SFU)
Abstract: Contamination is of paramount concern in ancient DNA studies as
it can potentially lead to false results. Although a dedicated DNA laboratory
can minimize the risk of cross-contamination during the DNA extraction and
analysis, it cannot control the contamination incurred by samples prior to
delivery to the laboratory. This pre- laboratory contamination creates an
immense challenge for ancient DNA work. It requires sophisticated research
designs for detection and great efforts for decontamination. In this study, we
propose a series of measures for the proper handling of remains intended for
ancient DNA analysis during excavation and subsequent processing. In addition,
considerations of methods to properly prepare samples of previously excavated
archaeological materials for DNA analysis are also discussed.
Title: mtDNA analysis of Archaic & Woodland Populations
and its implications
for Algonquian and Iroquoian Origins.